Kaytlin Bailey, founder of Old Pros and host of The Oldest Profession Podcast, passionately advocates for the rights of sex workers. She delves into the stigma faced by sex workers in the U.S., discussing how laws like SESTA-FOSTA can inadvertently increase risks. The conversation tackles whether promiscuity stigma is rooted in biology or cultural norms, and explores the impact of legal frameworks on workers' safety and autonomy. Bailey emphasizes the need for decriminalization and a broader understanding of sexuality, challenging misconceptions surrounding the profession.
The criminalization of sex work in the U.S. fosters vulnerability among sex workers, leading to exploitation and societal harm.
Legislation like SESTA-FOSTA, intended to combat trafficking, inadvertently restricts sex workers' safety and access to essential resources.
The podcast emphasizes the need for a nuanced understanding of consent in sex work, differentiating consensual practices from coercive circumstances.
Deep dives
The Criminalization of Sex Work
The overwhelming majority of sex work is criminalized in the United States, with only Nevada offering limited legal options in rural counties. This criminalization not only targets full-service sex work but also extends to various forms of sex work that occur online or through platforms. The stigma surrounding sex work fosters vulnerabilities among sex workers, making them susceptible to exploitation and violence. Caitlin Bailey asserts that this systemic oppression negatively impacts not only sex workers but society at large, emphasizing a need for change in legal and societal attitudes towards sex work.
The Impact of Technology and Legislation
Legislation such as SESTA-FOSTA has harmed the ability of sex workers to operate safely and utilize online platforms for their work. This law, initially framed as an effort to combat sex trafficking, has led to increased censorship of sexual content, making it harder for sex workers to connect and protect themselves. The sweeping measures taken against sex work online have also inadvertently reduced access to sexual health education and resources, affecting both sex workers and the general public. As a result, this legislation has fostered a climate of fear that limits freedom of expression and privacy for many individuals.
The Feminist Debate Around Sex Work
The podcast explores the contentious relationship between feminism and sex work, contrasting the views of different feminist perspectives. Some feminists perceive sex work as a form of exploitation that undermines women's rights, while advocates argue it should be seen as legitimate labor deserving protection. Caitlin Bailey believes that the stigma against sex work is rooted in misogyny and societal control over women's sexuality, and that feminist arguments should focus on empowering sex workers rather than dismantling their profession. She urges feminists to collaborate and support efforts advocating for the rights and safety of sex workers.
The Complex Nature of Consent and Coercion
The discussion highlights the complexities surrounding consent and coercion in the sex work industry. While many individuals engage in sex work voluntarily, a small percentage may be coerced due to various factors, including economic necessity or abusive relationships. Bailey emphasizes the importance of capturing the diverse experiences of sex workers, asserting that criminalization exacerbates vulnerabilities rather than protects them. She argues that acknowledging the difference between consensual sex work and trafficking is crucial for crafting more effective social and legal frameworks.
Changing Societal Attitudes Towards Sex Work
In recent years, societal attitudes towards sex work have been shifting, with younger generations displaying increased acceptance. This evolving perspective is partly influenced by the rise of platforms like OnlyFans, which have normalized the monetization of sexual content. However, there remains significant resistance, particularly from conservative factions and those perpetuating the stigma around sex work. Caitlin Bailey advocates for increased visibility for sex workers and their rights, stressing that informed conversations about sex work must address historical injustices and promote harm reduction strategies.
Why are sex workers treated so badly in the US? What effects do licensing requirements have on sex workers and their customers? How do sex worker rights connect with privacy rights more broadly? In what philosophical principles ought sex worker rights (and their customers' rights) to be grounded? How do sex work laws affect people who aren't sex workers? Is "whore-phobia" the root of all misogyny? Is misogyny built into human nature, or is it learned? How does testicle size affect evolutionary fitness? Must religions necessarily have rules and norms about sexual purity? How do the Abrahamic religions teach sexual purity, and to whom are these lessons taught? Do sex workers have more or fewer STIs than the average "civilian"? If Alice is a sex worker and has had sex with 20 partners, and Bridget is not a sex worker and has also had sex with 20 partners, then which of them is considered to be the more promiscuous of the two? What sorts of tools and processes do sex workers use to screen clients? Are sex workers harmed (psychologically, physically, etc.) more through sex work than the average person is harmed through their work? How common are pimps nowadays? What are the various legal models for sex work around the world? Why does there seem to be a strong connection between sex work and illegal drug use? Why are women more opposed than men to the legalization of sex work? Does legal sex work potentially encourage the objectification of women and thus increase misogyny?
Kaytlin Bailey is the founder and Executive Director of Old Pros, a nonprofit focused on changing the status of sex workers in society. She hosts The Oldest Profession Podcast and is currently touring her award-winning one-woman show Whore's Eye View, a comedic mad dash through 10,000 years of history from a sex worker's perspective. Old Pros sends out a weekly newsletter with a round up of sex worker rights news from around the world, upcoming live events, and new episodes of The Oldest Profession Podcast. Subscribe to that newsletter at oldprosonline.org, or interact on Twitter / X at @oldprosonline. To reach Kaytlin directly, send her an email at kaytlin@oldprosonline.org or message her on Twitter / X at @kaytlinbailey. To find upcoming tour dates for Whore's Eye View, visit whoreseyeview.com.