Justice Under Trump: SCOTUS & Mahmoud Khalil (with Kate Shaw)
Mar 20, 2025
auto_awesome
Kate Shaw, a constitutional law professor at the University of Pennsylvania, dives into the legal challenges arising from President Trump’s executive orders. She analyzes Elon Musk’s influence on governmental decisions and the shifting dynamics of the Supreme Court, particularly with Justice Amy Coney Barrett. The discussion also focuses on upcoming cases regarding birthright citizenship and transgender rights, and an intriguing examination of Mahmoud Khalil’s detention highlights the intersection of free speech and deportation under U.S. law.
The podcast discusses the constitutional implications of Trump's executive orders, underscoring a dangerous disconnect between legal processes and presidential actions.
Kate Shaw highlights the critical need for checks and balances, explaining that only Congress can amend federal agency functions established by statute.
The conversation examines First Amendment rights, particularly in Mahmoud Khalil's case, raising concerns about deportation based on speech-related activities.
Deep dives
The Significance of Staying Informed
The podcast emphasizes the critical need for individuals to remain engaged and informed in today's political climate, suggesting that the temptation to tune out is strong but dangerous. The host highlights that significant events are unfolding that could impact the future, making it vital for the public to stay attuned to developments. This overarching theme sets the stage for a discussion on various political and legal matters, particularly focusing on actions taken by former President Trump. The importance of involvement is underscored as a civic duty, especially when such actions may challenge foundational constitutional principles.
Challenges to Constitutional Law
The conversation with constitutional law expert Kate Shaw revolves around the unprecedented actions taken by Trump since taking office, particularly regarding executive orders and their implications for constitutional law. Shaw articulates that Trump's approach has not adhered to traditional, legally required processes for policy changes, leading to a disconnect between law and practice. She critiques the notion that dissatisfaction with Trump's policies stems solely from differing opinions, asserting that it is instead rooted in concerns about the administration's constitutional adherence. This highlights the tension between lawful governance and executive actions that may overstep authority.
The Role of the President and Agency Authority
The discussion explores the limits of presidential power concerning the dismantling of federal agencies, such as the Department of Education. Shaw explains that while a president can influence agency operations, they cannot unilaterally eliminate functions or roles established by statute without Congressional support. Conversely, she argues that Congress is the appropriate body to amend or eliminate these agencies, emphasizing a system of checks and balances. This segment highlights the constitutional framework that constrains executive power and reinforces the need for lawful procedures in policy implementation.
First Amendment Concerns with Deportation Efforts
The podcast shifts focus to the implications of Trump's administration on First Amendment rights, particularly in the case of Mahmoud Khalil, a Columbia student involved in pro-Palestinian protests. Legal analysts discuss the controversial decision to detain Khalil based on alleged speech activities, raising questions about the constitutional validity of such actions. The conversation underscores that First Amendment protections extend to non-citizens, pointing out that deportation based solely on speech would likely be unconstitutional. This segment examines the tension between national security claims and civil liberties, reflecting broader implications for free speech in America.
Judicial Expectations and Government Authority
Expert commentary addresses how the courts might respond to government assertions regarding national interest and the legal grounds for deportation cases like that of Khalil. Participants discuss the standards of proof required for the government to justify such deportations, noting that evidence must be compelling enough to meet judicial scrutiny. There are constitutional questions about whether the government's actions are grounded in lawful authority or if they are mere retaliations against dissenting voices. This analysis reveals the intricate relationship between executive power, statutory law, and the necessity for accountability in government actions.
Implications of Judicial Criticism
The dialogue extends into the realm of public criticism of judges and the constitutional balance of power in holding justices accountable. Analysts note that while judges should be able to withstand scrutiny, there is a fine line between legitimate criticism and threats to judicial independence. The conversation contextualizes the backlash against justices for their rulings, emphasizing the importance of protecting judicial integrity while also allowing for discourse on their decisions. Such discussions reflect the nuanced dynamics of political discourse, judicial authority, and First Amendment rights that are essential to a functioning democracy.
Kate Shaw is a constitutional law professor at University of Pennsylvania Penn Carey Law School. Shaw joins Preet to discuss legal challenges to President Trump’s executive orders and the constitutionality of Elon Musk’s role in DOGE. They also discuss whether Justice Amy Coney Barrett is shifting away from the conservative majority and upcoming Supreme Court cases on birthright citizenship and transgender care.
Plus, in a special excerpt from the CAFE Insider podcast, Preet and Joyce Vance speak with First Amendment expert Erwin Chemerinksy about the constitutionality of Trump’s attempt to deport Mahmoud Khalil based on his involvement in pro-Palestine protests at Columbia University. Visit cafe.com/insider to subscribe and hear the full conversation.
For show notes and a transcript of the episode head to our website.
Have a question for Preet? Ask @PreetBhararaon Twitter or Bluesky with the hashtag #AskPreet. Email us at staytuned@cafe.com, or call 833-997-7338 to leave a voicemail.
Stay Tuned with Preet is brought to you by CAFE and the Vox Media Podcast Network.
