“A soul that will not be satisfied” — The problem of human restlessness
Apr 5, 2023
auto_awesome
Richard College, an Associate Professor of Philosophy at Australian Catholic University, dives into the depths of human restlessness and the ancient philosophical insights that illuminate it. He explores the Arabic concept of 'nafs' as a symbol of our discontent and the vital connection between breath and spirit. The discussion highlights the struggle between ambition and tranquility, contrasting material pursuits with a quest for deeper fulfillment. College also emphasizes the importance of aligning desires with a transcendent purpose for true contentment.
The podcast challenges the notion of 'eventification,' proposing a redefinition of significant moments as meaningful life-altering experiences rather than mere spectacles.
It emphasizes the concept of moral incapacities within Ramadan, highlighting self-reflection's role in overcoming personal struggles for a morally integrated life.
The discussion explores the dual nature of human desire, recognizing its potential to motivate individuals while also leading to dissatisfaction if left unchecked.
Deep dives
Eventification of Modern Life
The discussion centers around the concept of 'eventification' in contemporary culture, where significant moments often become spectacles that divert attention from their deeper meanings. The speakers challenge the tendency of media to overly celebrate anniversaries and major events, suggesting that these moments may mark important inflection points in life experiences rather than mere celebrations. They propose redefining events as moments that fundamentally alter perspectives and lives, creating a meaningful distinction between significant occurrences and trivial spectacles. By engaging in this analysis, they invite listeners to contemplate the nature of events and their impact on moral and ethical considerations.
Understanding Moral Incapacities
The episode explores the idea of moral incapacities as defined by specific supplications in the context of Ramadan, emphasizing a series of soul-related themes derived from a prayer by the Prophet Muhammad. Listeners learn that these incapacities are not merely vices but represent fundamental challenges that inhibit one's ability to live a morally integral life. By framing these challenges as incapacities, the speakers highlight the importance of self-reflection and recognition of personal moral struggles to foster growth and change. The discussion is further enriched by examining the concepts of a heart that cannot humble itself, a prayer that is not heard, and a soul that is never satisfied.
The Concept of the Soul
The term 'nafs,' often translated as 'soul,' is analyzed in depth, revealing its multiple connotations and significance within Arabic language and culture. The speakers discuss how 'nafs' encompasses not only the idea of self but also resonates with concepts of breath and preciousness, emphasizing its integral role in human existence. This exploration contrasts 'nafs' with the Hebrew term 'ruah,' suggesting that understanding these nuances provides a richer perspective on the nature of the soul. Ultimately, the conversation underscores how acknowledging the multifaceted dimensions of the soul can inform our understanding of moral capabilities and limitations.
Philosophical Perspectives on Desire
The dialogue delves into philosophical considerations regarding human desire and its inherent restlessness, weaving together ideas from various thinkers, including Plato and Aristotle. The discussion highlights the parallels between ancient philosophies and contemporary issues, as the speakers discuss how desire can both motivate and deter individuals from achieving genuine fulfillment. They contemplate the dual nature of desire, acknowledging that while it drives individuals to seek more, it can also lead to dissatisfaction when those desires become disordered. By examining these philosophical insights, the episode encourages listeners to consider the implications of unchecked desire, including its potential to distract from more meaningful pursuits.
The Role of Practices in Moral Formation
The speakers emphasize the necessity of deliberate practices and rituals for fostering moral development and addressing desire's complexities. They propose that spiritual practices, such as fasting during Ramadan, serve as vital interruptions that can redirect focus and cultivate self-discipline. By highlighting the importance of sustaining moral practices, the conversation posits that these habits are essential for navigating the inherent restlessness of human desire. Ultimately, the episode argues that continuous engagement with moral practices is critical for achieving a balanced life and aligning desires with higher values.
For this third show in our Ramadan series, we’re asking what it is about the human condition that seems to drive it to perpetual discontentment? What is the virtue of repose, and when does “contentment” become indolence or conformity, a chronic lack of curiosity?
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode