A young woman with no memory arrives at a boarding house causing concern. Discover the ease of committing individuals to mental asylums and the bias against nonconforming women. Nellie Bly's shocking undercover investigation reveals the horrors of the New York City lunatic asylum. Explore Roosevelt Island's history and amenities and the transformation of the old asylum into luxury apartments. Uncover inequality in criminal justice and the mistreatment of women at the asylum. Learn about Nellie Bly's legacy and her efforts to expose corruption.
The New York City Lunatic Asylum on Blackwell's Island had overcrowded and inhumane conditions, leading to abuse, neglect, and mistreatment of patients.
Nellie Bly's undercover reporting exposed the appalling conditions in the asylum, prompting reforms in mental health institutions.
Deep dives
Conditions in the New York City Lunatic Asylum
The New York City Lunatic Asylum on Blackwell's Island opened in 1839 and quickly became overcrowded. Patients suffered from horrendous conditions, including overcrowded rooms, lack of proper clothing and food, and physical abuse from staff. The asylum failed to provide the humane treatment promised by the moral treatment approach. Exposés and investigations led to some improvements, but conditions remained dire until the asylum closed in 1901.
Nellie Bly: An Undercover Reporter's Experience
Nellie Bly, an undercover reporter for the New York World, infiltrated the New York City Lunatic Asylum on Blackwell's Island. Bly witnessed horrifying abuse, neglect, and mistreatment of patients, including physical violence, inadequate food, cold temperatures, and unsanitary conditions. Her reporting shed light on the appalling conditions and prompted reforms in mental health institutions.
Unfulfilled Promises and Lingering Inequalities
Efforts to improve conditions in the New York City Lunatic Asylum often fell short, with reforms being temporary and insufficient. Class and gender biases played a significant role in who ended up in the asylum, with poor women being disproportionately affected. Wealthy individuals had access to private institutions or escaped criminal charges altogether. The legacy of unequal treatment and mistreatment of the mentally ill persisted, highlighting enduring problems in mental health care and societal attitudes.
When a young woman showed up at a boarding house in Manhattan, she said her name was Nellie Brown – but that was all she seemed to remember about herself. Soon, people became scared of her. Someone went to the police: "I want you to take her quietly."
Travis Russ' upcoming play is The Gorgeous Nothings. To hear our special bonus episode about the other end of the island—and get ad-free listening, members-only merch and more—sign up for Criminal Plus.
Criminal is going back on tour in February! We’ll be telling brand new stories, live on stage. You can even get meet and greet tickets to come and say hi before the show. Tickets are on sale now at thisiscriminal.com/live. We can’t wait to see you there!