The Toyota Way: Responding to, Preventing and Learning from Mistakes with Jeff Liker
Feb 14, 2024
auto_awesome
Jeff Liker, author of the Toyota Way series, discusses learning from mistakes within organizations that employ Toyota Production System. He shares insights on Toyota's culture of continuous improvement, the role of leadership in problem solving, and the significance of the andon cord system. The episode also explores the challenge of changing deeply embedded habits in leaders and the importance of assessing an organization's compatibility for help. Additionally, it discusses the challenges faced during the implementation of the team leader role at Ford's truck plant. Off-topic discussions about playing classical guitar conclude the episode.
Psychological safety is crucial for Lean implementation and continuous improvement.
Creating and sustaining a Lean culture requires ongoing training and leadership commitment.
Toyota's team leader role is instrumental in fostering a culture of accountability and continuous improvement.
Deep dives
Importance of Psychological Safety and Speaking Up
Psychological safety, the feeling of safety to speak up, is crucial in organizations embracing Lean. In Toyota plants, where problem-solving and continuous improvement are fundamental, employees are expected to pull the Andon cord to signal issues. The culture fosters an understanding that problems exist in any process, and improvement can only happen if gaps between what should be happening and what actually happens are acknowledged. However, in Western culture, terms like psychological safety are used to describe this concept. Toyota in Japan focuses more on the practical aspects of problem-solving rather than emphasizing psychological safety. Nonetheless, creating a psychologically safe environment where employees feel secure and encouraged to admit mistakes is essential for Lean implementation and continuous improvement efforts.
The Challenges in Sustaining Lean Culture
Developing and maintaining a Lean culture can be challenging, especially when faced with organizational changes, managerial shifts, and external pressures. Toyota has experienced ups and downs in different plants and regions when implementing Lean practices. Factors such as layoffs, external hiring, and leadership turnover can directly impact the continuity of the Lean culture. Efforts to sustain a Lean culture include ongoing training, using model line projects to reinforce Lean principles, and developing coaches to support continuous improvement. Success often depends on a leader's commitment and ability to create an environment where employees feel safe to voice their opinions and ideas.
The Role of Leadership in Encouraging Continuous Improvement
Leaders play a vital role in fostering a culture of continuous improvement. In the Toyota Way, leaders are expected to show respect for their employees, treat them fairly, and prioritize their psychological and physical safety. Leaders must be trusted by their employees, encouraging transparency and trust in the organization. Psychological safety allows employees to admit mistakes, report problems, and engage in problem-solving activities. Leaders are responsible for challenging the status quo, setting clear expectations, providing mentorship and support, and facilitating an environment where continuous improvement is valued and rewarded.
The Impact of Toyota's Team Leader Role in Creating Accountability
Toyota's team leader role is instrumental in fostering a culture of accountability. Team leaders, who are selected based on their problem-solving capabilities and leadership potential, are responsible for responding to Andon pulls and leading problem-solving efforts. The team leader's role is non-managerial, but they are trained deeply in problem-solving skills and given the authority to make decisions. The team leader is accountable for addressing issues within their areas of responsibility, working with the group leader when necessary. Team leaders serve as role models and coaches for team members, creating accountability and reinforcing the importance of continuous improvement.
The Importance of Problem-Solving and Seeing Gaps in Lean Culture
Problem-solving is at the core of Lean culture, where gaps between what should be happening and what actually happens are addressed. In Toyota, the philosophy is that no problem is a problem. This mindset creates a context where people view deviations from standards, Andon calls, and gaps between actual and desired outcomes as opportunities for improvement. The practice of going to the Gemba, the actual work area, helps individuals see and understand the gaps, facilitating problem-solving and learning. Recognizing and acknowledging problems is essential for driving continuous improvement and cultivating a Lean culture.
He was previously a guest here in Episodes 3, 4, 37, 39, 41, 111, and 400.
Today, we have a discussion centered around learning from mistakes in the context of Toyota and lean methodologies. The episode delves into the significance of recognizing, reacting to, and learning from mistakes within organizations that employ Toyota Production System (TPS) or lean strategies. Jeff shares his insights on how Toyota's culture of continuous improvement and learning from errors fundamentally drives its success. The conversation touches on Toyota's approach to leadership and problem-solving, emphasizing the structured response to mistakes at different levels of the organization, from the factory floor to top management.
The episode further explores the Toyota leadership model, illustrating how leaders at various levels are expected to react when mistakes occur. Liker explains the role of the andon cord system in facilitating immediate problem identification and resolution, showcasing Toyota's commitment to quality and efficiency. He elaborates on the multi-layered leadership response to errors, detailing the responsibilities of team leaders, group leaders, and higher management in fostering a culture of learning and improvement. The discussion underscores the importance of a systemic approach to problem-solving, where the focus is on understanding and addressing the root causes of mistakes rather than attributing blame to individuals. This episode offers valuable insights into the principles of lean leadership and the critical role of acknowledging and learning from mistakes in achieving organizational excellence and innovation.
Questions, Notes, and Highlights:
How you'd expect Toyota leaders to react to a mistake on the factory floor?
Less likely to blame an individual?
Root cause vs. controllable cause?
That can be a tough lesson to teach other companies?
Hardest habit to break is the blame habit?
Mistakes people make in trying to help change behavior
What's necessary, in another company's workplace culture, for people to feel safe pulling the andon cord or speaking up?
The podcast is brought to you by Stiles Associates, the premier executive search firm specializing in the placement of Lean Transformation executives. With a track record of success spanning over 30 years, it's been the trusted partner for the manufacturing, private equity, and healthcare sectors. Learn more.
