Historian Dr. Eleanor Janega and Matt Lewis discuss Harold Godwinson, Harald Hardrada, and William the Conqueror's race for power in 1066. They delve into England's centralization, Harold's alliances, and the strategic significance of the kingdom. The podcast explores Harold's unconventional path to the throne, his coronation, and the quest for legitimacy in a turbulent political landscape.
Harold Godwinson's political acumen and knowledge of English system shaped his reign and decision-making.
Competition for English throne highlighted by economic opportunities, political prestige, and concept of might making right.
Deep dives
Harold Godwinson: The Ill-Fated King of England
Harold Godwinson, despite being remembered as a failed king, was a prominent and influential figure in England. He had diplomatic dealings with Duke William of Normandy, fought against Welsh kings, and played a significant role in English politics. His rise to the throne was marked by the question of succession, and he tried to secure his position by marrying into the most powerful local family. However, his lack of an heir and opposition from other factions led to a power vacuum upon Edward the Confessor's death, and Harold seized the opportunity to become king. The haste with which he was elected and crowned highlights the challenges and uncertainties he faced. While Harold achieved victories against Harold Hardrada and came close to defeating William the Conqueror, his decision to offer battle to William ultimately led to his downfall. Despite this, Harold Godwinson's reign showcased his knowledge of the English political system and his ability to navigate complex political landscapes.
The Desire to Conquer England
England, with its wealth and political unity, was an attractive target for conquest. The kingdom offered economic opportunities, such as the wool trade, and political prestige, allowing rulers to rub shoulders with other influential European monarchs. The ease with which England could be conquered in comparison to regions like Wales or southern Italy made it an enticing prospect. The allure of kingship and membership in an elite club of rulers also motivated contenders like William the Conqueror, Harold Hardrada, and Harold Godwinson to vie for the English throne. The competition for England exemplified the concept of might making right, as each claimant sought to establish their legitimacy and authority through conquest.
The Gamble of Battle and its Consequences
Harold Godwinson's decision to offer battle to William the Conqueror, fresh off his victory against Harold Hardrada, proved to be a high-risk gamble. While Harold may have hoped to catch William off guard and score another decisive victory, it ultimately led to his defeat and death at the Battle of Hastings. The haste with which Harold assumed the throne and his desire to protect his family and homeland may have contributed to his decision. However, offering battle to William played into the conqueror's strategy and allowed him to assert his claim to the English throne. In hindsight, this fateful decision was crucial in shaping the course of English history.
Assessment of the Claimants: Harold Godwinson, Harold Hardrada, and William the Conqueror
Among the three claimants to the English throne, Harold Godwinson appears to be the most attractive option. He had a strong understanding of the English political system and exhibited consensual rule during his short reign. While not without flaws, Harold showed a level of care for his people and a willingness to compromise when necessary. In contrast, William the Conqueror's success came at a great cost, with his rule marked by bloodshed and a disregard for the well-being of his subjects. Harold Hardrada was an ambitious monarch, but his ultimate defeat by Harold Godwinson showcased the latter's military prowess and strategic acumen. Despite the complexities and challenges each claimant faced, Harold Godwinson emerges as the least worst option.
Dr Eleanor Janega and Matt Lewis uncover the stories of the protagonists and events that led up to the Battle of Hastings. There’s Harold Godwinson, the Anglo-Saxon Lord who became the king of a people only recently brought together; Harald Hardrada, a legendary Viking warrior seeking to rebuild the North Sea Empire to which he believes himself heir; and William the Conqueror, descended from pagan Vikings, now the Christian Duke of Normandy. The lives of millions of people for centuries to come will be inextricably linked to their actions in that fateful year of 1066.
In this first episode, Eleanor finds out more about Harold Godwinson from Professor Levi Roach.
This episode was produced by Rob Weinberg.
Enjoy unlimited access to award-winning original documentaries that are released weekly and AD-FREE podcasts. Get a subscription for £1 per month for 3 months with code DANSNOW sign up at https://historyhit/subscription/
We'd love to hear from you- what do you want to hear an episode on? You can email the podcast at ds.hh@historyhit.com.
