In this enlightening conversation, Thomas Nagel, a prominent American philosopher renowned for his exploration of consciousness, ethics, and the limits of scientific thought, shares his profound insights. He discusses the intricacies of subjective experience and challenges the materialistic view of consciousness. Nagel also delves into the ethics of animal suffering and the difficulty of reconciling personal loyalties with impartial moral theories. He emphasizes the need for a broader perspective on reality that unites both the mental and physical realms.
01:03:24
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
menu_book Books
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
insights INSIGHT
Subjectivity Limits Knowing Experience
Conscious mental states have an irreducibly subjective aspect that physical terms cannot capture.
The subjective nature of experience limits our understanding of other species' perspectives, like bats using echolocation.
insights INSIGHT
Understanding Other Minds Limitations
Closer physiological similarity increases our capacity to understand another's experience.
Literature aids imagining perspectives distinct from our own but there's always some limit, especially across species.
insights INSIGHT
Challenges in Quantifying Animal Suffering
Comparing suffering intensity across species is complex and uncertain.
Recognizing animal pain, like lobsters', is advancing laws against cruel practices such as boiling alive.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Thomas Nagel's essay "What Is It Like to Be a Bat?" is a seminal work in philosophy of mind. It explores the subjective nature of consciousness and the challenges of understanding other minds. Nagel argues that even with complete physical knowledge of a bat's brain, we cannot fully grasp its subjective experience. This essay highlights the limitations of reductionist approaches to consciousness. It continues to be a central text in discussions about qualia, subjective experience, and the mind-body problem.
Mortal Questions
Thomas Nagel
Mortal Questions by Thomas Nagel delves into profound issues related to the meaning, nature, and value of human life. The book addresses topics such as attitudes toward death, sexual behavior, social inequality, war, and political power, leading to deeper philosophical discussions on personal identity, consciousness, freedom, and value. It offers a blend of theoretical and personal insights into life's most critical questions.
Freedom and Reason.
Freedom and Reason.
R.M. Hare
Focus on What Matters
None
Darius Faurot
Looking for Spinoza
Antonio Damasio
In 'Looking for Spinoza', Antonio Damasio explores the neurobiology of emotions and their role in human life, drawing on the philosophical insights of Baruch Spinoza. The book delves into how emotions and feelings are rooted in the brain's perception of bodily states, and how this understanding aligns with Spinoza's views on the interconnectedness of mind and body. Damasio's work combines scientific research with historical and philosophical perspectives to offer a comprehensive view of human emotions and their significance.
The Point of View of the Universe
Henry Sidgwick
The view from nowhere
Thomas Nagel
Weighing Animal Welfare
Weighing Animal Welfare
Bob Fischer
How to Do Things with Words
How to Do Things with Words
J.L. Austin
J.L. Austin's "How to Do Things with Words" is a highly influential work in the philosophy of language. It introduces the concept of speech acts, arguing that language is not merely descriptive but also performative. Austin distinguishes between constative utterances (statements that describe) and performative utterances (statements that do something), such as making a promise or issuing a command. He analyzes the conditions under which performative utterances are successful, highlighting the social and contextual factors that shape their meaning and effect. The book has had a profound impact on linguistics, philosophy, and literary theory.
The possibility of altruism
Thomas Nagel
Thomas Nagel is an American philosopher known for exploring consciousness, ethics, and the limits of scientific explanation. He is best known for his essay "What Is It Like to Be a Bat?" and his critique of materialism in Mind and Cosmos.
Thomas discusses how he was drawn to philosophy, he elaborates on the major themes of his work, especially the challenge of understanding the subjective experience, and calls for a broader view of reality that encompasses both mental and physical dimensions.
Beyond philosophy of mind, Nagel discusses ethical issues, such as the difficulty of comparing the suffering of different species and the tensions between impartial moral theories and personal loyalties.
Lives Well Lived 
