
The Commentary Magazine Podcast Look Who's Talking Nicely About MAGA
25 snips
Nov 14, 2025 The discussion dives into whether MAGA can survive without Trump as the media claims fractures in the movement. Panelists ponder Trump's drift from traditional populism due to his lavish lifestyle. Is MAGA synonymous with unwavering loyalty to Trump? They explore if dissatisfaction within the base is genuine or a media exaggeration. The risks Trump faces are examined, focusing on macroeconomic issues over internal conflicts. Plus, the potential for a strong economy to buffer a troubled presidency and speculations around future impeachment scenarios add to the intrigue.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
MAGA And Trump Are Essentially One
- The hosts argue there is effectively no separation between MAGA and Donald Trump as a movement and leader.
- Trump embodies MAGA largely through personal fealty rather than a coherent ideological program.
Non‑MAGA Republicans Are Restive, Not Revolting
- Many Republicans who aren’t ardent MAGA supporters still give Trump leeway because they trust his policy achievements.
- They are restive about issues like tariffs and prices but not ready to abandon him.
Occasional Policy Divergences Don’t Break The Base
- Trump sometimes diverges from his most ardent supporters on issues like vaccines and Ukraine, creating occasional daylight.
- Those divergences rarely translate into a sustained split because base loyalty centers on him personally.



