3 and Out with John Middlekauff Is Caleb Williams a BUST, QB and Coach relationship, 49ers CUT Moody
Sep 10, 2025
Caleb Williams faces scrutiny after a rough game, raising doubts about his future with the Bears. The podcast highlights the critical bond between quarterbacks and coaches, showcasing how this relationship can dictate success. The 49ers' shocking decision to cut kicker Moody is analyzed, pondering its implications for the team's future. Listeners also enjoy a mailbag segment, tackling various questions about the NFL dynamics and coaching strategies.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Why Ben Johnson Was Hired
- Ben Johnson was hired because he can coach and resurrect quarterbacks, reducing draft risk for Caleb Williams.
- John Middlekauff believes Caleb's erratic, timing-averse play likely won't fit Johnson's timing-based offense.
Caleb Williams’ Early Inconsistency
- Caleb Williams displayed extreme inconsistency across his first 18 games, swinging from overwhelmed to spectacular.
- Middlekauff warns that freelancing and timing issues make him a risky long-term starter.
Give Coaches Time, But Not Too Much
- Hire offensive coaches who can adapt quarterbacks to a timing-based system if traits mismatch.
- Monitor progress early; teams now give about two seasons before pivoting.