Sally Shrapnell, an Associate Professor in Physics, and Peter Harrison, a Research Fellow and Emeritus Professor in the Humanities, dive into the purpose of philosophy. They tackle the discipline's historical biases, such as sexism and colonialism, revealing how these injustices persist today. The discussion expands to the relationship between philosophy and science, questioning the nature of truth and the influence of narrative in moral understanding. They also confront the challenges posed by misinformation in the modern era, emphasizing philosophy’s role in navigating societal dilemmas.
Philosophy faces scrutiny about its relevance, with critics questioning its ability to produce measurable results compared to the sciences.
The need for inclusivity in philosophy is emphasized, addressing historical biases and advocating for diverse voices to enrich the discourse.
Philosophy's role in addressing contemporary societal challenges highlights the importance of interdisciplinary collaboration to navigate complex issues beyond rational discourse.
Deep dives
The Utility of Philosophy
Philosophy is often acknowledged for its significance, yet it has faced critiques regarding its relevance and impact. Critics question whether philosophy is truly valuable, suggesting that it often revisits the same questions without progress. In light of this, there's a growing conversation about how philosophy can engage with contemporary issues beyond traditional boundaries. The dialogue emphasizes that exploring philosophical perspectives can enrich understanding in various fields, including science and the humanities.
Philosophical Baggage and Inclusivity
The discussion raises concerns about the historical biases within philosophy, particularly regarding gender and race. Traditional philosophical frameworks have often been perceived as male-dominated and Eurocentric, leading to the marginalization of diverse voices. Acknowledging the contributions of women and Indigenous philosophies, some contemporary philosophers advocate for a broader scope that includes varied cultural perspectives. This inclusivity aims to challenge and expand the philosophical canon to reflect a richer array of human experiences.
The Role of Reason in Philosophy
Philosophy's emphasis on reason and rational discourse has drawn both praise and criticism. While reason plays a central role in many philosophical inquiries, it is argued that this focus can overlook intuitive and emotional understanding. Some philosophers contend that a more holistic approach, incorporating aesthetics and human experiences, can enhance philosophical discussions. This evolving landscape suggests that philosophical inquiry may need to adapt to fully address complex human experiences and challenges.
Philosophy and Modern Science
There is an ongoing debate in which modern science is seen as having surpassed philosophy in providing knowledge about the world. Prominent figures in science have dismissed philosophy as irrelevant, claiming it lacks the empirical rigor of scientific inquiry. However, proponents of philosophy argue that philosophical analysis is crucial for addressing foundational questions that science cannot answer alone. This discussion highlights the interdependence of philosophy and science in the pursuit of knowledge and understanding.
Philosophy's Response to Contemporary Issues
Philosophy is often positioned as a tool for navigating the complexities of modern societal challenges, including the rise of conspiracy theories and irrational beliefs. While some scholars advocate for philosophical education as a remedy to counteract misinformation, others emphasize the importance of understanding the socio-cultural factors at play. This acknowledgment that mere education may not suffice suggests a deeper exploration of identity and values is necessary. Ultimately, the discussion indicates that while philosophy has much to offer, it may require collaboration with other disciplines to effectively engage with contemporary issues.
Does philosophy answer questions, or just keep asking them over and over again? Some say that compared to the sciences, philosophy has few runs on the board when it comes to measurable results. And then there's the issue of sexism in the discipline, and Western philosophy's colonial past. In this live panel discussion recorded in Brisbane, we put philosophy's feet to the fire.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode