KQED's Forum If We Are in an AI Bubble, What Happens if it Pops?
Nov 5, 2025
In this discussion, tech journalist Brian Merchant and Atlantic staff writer Charlie Warzel dissect the potential of AI as the ultimate financial bubble. Merchant highlights soaring valuations and the danger of inflated expectations, while Warzel analyzes the staggering scale of investments and their concentration among major companies. They explore the cyclical investment dependencies within the industry and debate whether current AI tools truly deliver on their promises. The duo also addresses the societal impact of automation and the environmental concerns surrounding data centers.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Investment Scale And Concentration
- AI investment has become enormous and concentrated, with global spending near $400B and most S&P gains driven by AI stocks.
- A handful of firms and chips (like NVIDIA) sit at the center of a vast, circular investment flow.
Circular Investment Creates Fragility
- AI financing flows are circular: firms invest in each other and in chipmakers, creating an Ouroboros of capital.
- That circularity raises vulnerability because if the flow stops, valuations could collapse rapidly.
Data Centers Require Enormous Revenue
- Data center spending outstrips current AI revenues, creating a massive revenue shortfall for break-even.
- Charlie Warzel cites estimates that AI firms need $320–$480B to cover just this year's data center costs.
