

John McWhorter & Jason Riley – The Affirmative Action Myth
37 snips May 16, 2025
Jason Riley, a Senior Fellow at the Manhattan Institute and author of 'The Affirmative Action Myth', dives deep into the complexities surrounding affirmative action. He argues that these policies often benefit the already advantaged while neglecting lower-income Blacks. The conversation also addresses shifting narratives on Black responsibility, emphasizing personal accountability over systemic racism. Riley critiques prominent figures like Ibram X. Kendi and advocates for a return to colorblind policies, suggesting that true progress lies in competition and self-sufficiency.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Black Progress Before Affirmative Action
- Significant Black middle class progress occurred before affirmative action's late 1960s start.
- Affirmative action since then has not accelerated but often slowed broad Black progress.
Affirmative Action's Mixed Educational Impact
- Bans on racial preferences reduced Black enrollment at elite schools but boosted overall enrollment and graduation rates.
- Affirmative action policies have sometimes limited broader Black educational and professional success.
Flaws in "The Shape of the River"
- "The Shape of the River" ignores the mismatch problem of admitting lower-qualified Black students.
- Black students admitted under lower standards struggle more, but the book groups all Black students together.