Guests dive into the true crime phenomenon, exploring its societal impact and ethical considerations. They discuss the emotional challenges faced by journalists, emphasizing the importance of respecting victims' families. The allure of true crime lies in unraveling mysteries while treading carefully in portraying real-life stories sensitively.
True crime narratives provide deep insights into societal issues beyond the crimes themselves.
Balancing entertainment with ethical storytelling is crucial in adapting true crime stories to screen.
Approaching families of victims with sensitivity is essential in investigative journalism.
Deep dives
The Intriguing Life of Zach Bretler
Zach Bretler's mysterious double life as a 19-year-old who met a tragic end in a luxury apartment played a central role in revealing his hidden identity to his grieving parents, Matthew and Rochelle Bretler. As the investigation unfolds, the discovery of Zach's connections to dangerous individuals sheds light on the complexities surrounding his death. Writer Patrick Radden Keefe delves into the emotional journey of the Bretler parents as they come to terms with the reality of their son's secret life and tragic fate.
Exploring Sensitivity in Crime Stories
Patrick Radden Keefe's experience in investigating crime stories emphasizes the importance of approaching families of victims with sensitivity and respect. Balancing the role of an investigative journalist with ethical considerations, Keefe navigates through the complexities of telling stories that involve real-life tragedies. From the emotive recounting of Amy Bishop's family to solving cold case murders like the one in 'Say Nothing,' Keefe's approach highlights the need to illuminate larger societal issues while respecting the impact on grieving families.
Telling Compelling Narratives in True Crime
Merging elements of suspense, empathy, and sociological insights, various true crime narratives captivate audiences by delving into the extremes of human experiences. Examples like Robert Kolker's 'The Lost Girls' provide profound perspectives on victims, transforming them from aliases to poignant personal stories. Keefe's work reflects a complex balance of engaging storytelling with a focus on real victims and their families, inviting readers to connect deeply with the human aspects behind each crime.
Challenges in Adaptations of True Crime Stories
The transition of true crime narratives from print to screen poses challenges in maintaining factual accuracy and ethical storytelling standards. Patrick Radden Keefe grapples with the balance between entertainment value and ethical considerations in dramatizations of his investigative works. As a producer on adaptations like 'Say Nothing,' Keefe navigates the fine line between creative liberties and honoring the real stories and individuals at the heart of his investigative reporting.
The Compelling Allure of True Crime
Patrick Radden Keefe and fellow critics explore the multi-faceted appeal of true crime narratives, dissecting their blend of suspense, historical context, and societal reflections. From iconic crime stories like 'In Cold Blood' to contemporary adaptations, the fascination with crime storytelling lies in its capacity to engage, provoke thought, and uncover deeper truths about human nature and society. The enduring intrigue of true crime highlights its role as a powerful conduit for storytelling and cultural exploration.
Over the past several years, true crime’s hold on the culture has tightened into a vice grip, with new titles flooding podcast charts and streaming platforms on a daily basis. This week on Critics at Large, Vinson Cunningham, Naomi Fry, and Alexandra Schwartz take stock of the phenomenon, first by speaking with fans of the genre to understand its appeal. Then, onstage at the 2024 Cascade PBS Ideas Festival, they continue the discussion with The New Yorker’s Patrick Radden Keefe, whose books “Empire of Pain” and “Say Nothing” are exemplars of the form. The panel considers Keefe’s recent piece, “The Oligarch’s Son,” which illuminates the journalistic challenges of reporting on sordid events—not least the difficulty of managing the emotions and expectations of victims’ families. As its appeal has skyrocketed, true crime has come under greater scrutiny. The most successful entries bypass lurid details and shed light on the society in which these transgressions occur. But “the price you have to pay in sociology, in anthropology, in enriching our understanding of something beyond the crime itself—it’s fairly high,” Keefe says. “You have to remember that this is a real story about real people. They’re alive. They’re out there.”
This episode was recorded on May 4, 2024 at the Cascade PBS Ideas Festival, in Seattle, Washington.
Read, watch, and listen with the critics:
“UK True Crime Podcast” “My Favorite Murder” “Empire of Pain,” by Patrick Radden Keefe “Say Nothing,” by Patrick Radden Keefe “Paradise Lost,” by John Milton “A Loaded Gun,” by Patrick Radden Keefe (The New Yorker) “The Oligarch’s Son,” by Patrick Radden Keefe (The New Yorker) “Capote” (2005) “In Cold Blood,” by Truman Capote (The New Yorker) “The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst” (2015, 2024) “Helter Skelter: The True Story of the Manson Murders,” by Curt Gentry and Vincent Bugliosi “Law & Order” (1990–) “Dahmer—Monster: The Jeffrey Dahmer Story” (2022) “The People v. O. J. Simpson: American Crime Story” (2016) “O.J.: Made in America” (2016) “Lost Girls: An Unsolved American Mystery,” by Robert Kolker
New episodes drop every Thursday. Follow Critics at Large wherever you get your podcasts.
