Critics at Large | The New Yorker

Dive into the chaos of Ari Aster's film 'Eddington,' which mirrors the turmoil of 2020 with its themes of societal dysfunction. The hosts dissect the challenges artists face when confronting America's chaotic reality, referencing Philip Roth and Tom Wolfe. Discussions range from nihilism in American culture to the intricate navigation of human connection during turbulent times. They also draw parallels to the legendary film 'Apocalypse Now,' revealing how art strives to make sense of a fragmented society.

The hosts dive into the evolution of romantic comedies, debating whether new films can capture the thrill of the classics. They discuss contemporary works like 'Materialists' and 'Too Much,' exploring themes of love, materialism, and societal expectations. The conversation reflects on how these films mirror shifting ideals and challenge traditional gender roles. Insights into character chemistry, the balance of fantasy and reality, and the complexities of modern relationships keep the dialogue lively and thought-provoking.

This discussion dives into the paradox of modern travel amidst social media's overwhelming influence. It highlights the shift towards awareness and cultural engagement in tourism, questioning the ethics of exploration. The speakers explore the rich legacy of travel literature, from Marco Polo to travel shows, reinforcing the quest for authenticity. They tackle the emotional ties to travel, the complexities of privilege, and how experiences shape our identities. Ultimately, they provoke thought on why we continue to seek connections in distant lands.

Michael Schulman, a renowned critic and author known for his engaging profiles in show business, joins the conversation about the cultural significance of 'divas.' They explore iconic figures like Patti LuPone, discussing the duality of talent and tumultuous behavior. Schulman emphasizes the ongoing fascination with these larger-than-life personas and how they navigate accountability in today's world. From Maria Callas to modern icons like Beyoncé, the dialogue examines how societal norms shape our definitions of divahood, intertwining admiration with scrutiny.

Delve into the profound connection between grief and art through Yiyun Li's candid memoir about losing her sons. The hosts examine how creativity can articulate deep sorrow, revealing the limitations of language in expressing such pain. Various artistic works, from Tennyson's poetry to stand-up specials, highlight the transformative power of grief. They discuss the duality of emotions in loss, the role of humor, and the communal nature of mourning, showcasing how art can offer solace in turbulent times.

The podcast dives into the timeless allure of Jane Austen, highlighting her keen social commentary and complex characters. The hosts celebrate favorites like 'Emma' and 'Pride and Prejudice,' discussing themes of love, societal constraints, and the intricate dance of irony and sincerity in her storytelling. They also explore the challenges faced by characters within their social contexts, pondering Austen's enigmatic life. The conversation connects her enduring legacy to contemporary issues, showcasing the relevance of her narratives in today’s world.

The podcast dives into Jesse Armstrong's new film, exploring the satirical portrayal of tech billionaires. It critiques how figures like Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg seek public approval, revealing their vulnerabilities. Discussions highlight the challenges of satirizing the absurdity of billionaire culture in today’s media landscape. The panel also examines the historical context of wealth in literature and how contemporary tales like 'Mountainhead' reflect societal inequities. Ultimately, it questions the maturity and public perception of the 'pathetic billionaire' archetype.

Dive into the fascinating legacy of a beloved children's show that has shaped generations. Discover how it transformed from a simple educational tool into a complex reflection of societal changes. Hear about a poignant moment involving loss and how it contrasts with today’s quick content. Explore concerns about its evolution, including recent shifts in production and accessibility on streaming platforms. The hosts also emphasize the need to balance innovation with the cherished traditions that define the show's heart and soul.

Dive into the nostalgia of summer with a discussion on how cultural obsessions define us. The hosts share tales of formative experiences linked to music and literature, from Brandy’s iconic album to impactful novels like Elena Ferrante’s. Listeners reveal their own summer fables, exploring the emotional ties and personal growth that come from these cherished connections. Reflecting on how past obsessions shape our identities today, the conversation weaves through the joy of artistic discovery and the significance of shared memories.

Paul Elie, a New Yorker writer focused on the Catholic Church, shares his insights from the Vatican as the world buzzes over the election of Pope Leo XIV. The discussion dives into the excitement surrounding Pope Leo's election, highlighting how modern media shapes public engagement with the papacy. The hosts explore pop culture's portrayal of popes, with critiques of shows like 'The Young Pope.' They also reflect on a resurgence in spiritual interest in the wake of recent events and the hopeful message of the new pope's leadership amidst contemporary challenges.