The TK Show: A Show about sports in the Bay Area [TK Show] A Conversation With NFL Analyst John Middlekauff
10 snips
Sep 18, 2025 
John Middlekauff, an NFL analyst and podcast host, dives deep into the 49ers' recent personnel decisions. He evaluates their choice to pass on Mac Jones, explaining why he fits better as a backup. With Brock Purdy's injury concerns hanging over the team, John highlights the risks of playing him versus prioritizing the playoffs. He also critiques the 49ers' risky offseason moves and emphasizes the importance of offensive line continuity. Plus, insights on Robert Saleh’s impact and coaching comparisons with Jim Harbaugh make for an engaging conversation.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Why The Trey Lance Trade Felt Reckless
- Kyle Shanahan valued taking high-ceiling QB swings despite risk, calling the trade for Trey Lance emotional and reckless in hindsight.
- Mac Jones fits more as a competent backup than a top-15 pick according to John Middlekauff.
Prioritize Starter Health Over Single Games
- Don’t rush returning an injured starter; protect season-long value by waiting until recovery is safe.
- Prioritize Brock Purdy’s availability because missing him could cost playoff chances in close games.
Shanahan's Coach-First Roster Mindset
- Kyle Shanahan approaches roster building like a coach reading a depth chart, favoring immediate positional fits over abstract 'best player available.'
- That coaching-driven control explains many 49ers moves and why they prioritize familiar scheme fits.