Alice Hunt, author of 'Republic: Britain’s Revolutionary Decade, 1649-1660', dives into the radical 11 years that followed the beheading of King Charles I. She unveils the rich tapestry of cultural and scientific developments during this time, spotlighting the contributions of figures like Cromwell and Samuel Hartlib. Hunt dispels common myths about Cromwell's legacy and explores how this turbulent period paved the way for modern governance in Britain, highlighting the societal ramifications of the republican experiment.
The execution of King Charles I in 1649 not only shocked the nation but also initiated a complex dialogue on governance and legitimacy in England.
Oliver Cromwell's rule during the Republic challenged traditional monarchy and fostered significant advancements in political discourse, science, and culture.
Deep dives
Pride's Purge and the Establishment of the Republic
Pride's Purge stands out as a critical turning point in British history, as it enabled the House of Commons to proceed with the trial of King Charles I. On December 6, 1648, Colonel Pride barred certain MPs from entering Parliament, paving the way for a radical faction to take control and ultimately find the King guilty. This purge highlighted the deep divisions among parliamentarians regarding the monarchy and set the stage for the establishment of the Republic. Consequently, the King was executed, marking the end of a monarchy that had long been perceived as divinely ordained.
The Impact of the Regicide on National Sentiment
The execution of Charles I in 1649 deeply affected the national psyche, eliciting shock and anguish from many, including those who supported his trial. Amidst a crowded Whitehall, a collective groan reportedly emerged as the King was beheaded, showcasing the gravity of the act on both royalists and republicans alike. Figures like Sir Thomas Fairfax, though opposed to the King, were troubled by the perceived illegitimacy of an act driven by a purged Parliament lacking comprehensive representation. This moment of regicide shaped subsequent attitudes toward governance and legitimacy in England, creating a conflict between monarchists and republicans that persisted throughout the 1650s.
Cromwell's Legacy and Modern Theoretical Reflections
Oliver Cromwell's legacy continues to generate complex discussions about governance and authority in England, highlighting the nuances of his rule during the Republic. Contrary to the simplistic view of him as a tyrant, Cromwell actively rejected the title of king, aiming instead for a system of governance that required popular consent. His administration facilitated notable achievements in political discourse, intersecting with significant scientific and cultural advancements of the era, exemplified by prominent figures like John Milton and Samuel Pepys. Today, as Britain reassesses its own constitutional arrangements, the revolutionary decade offers profound lessons about the future of governance and the monarchy's place within it.
For some, it's hard to imagine Britain without a king or queen. Yet, nearly 400 years ago, that prospect became a reality. In January 1649, after a bloody civil war, King Charles I was put on trial, found guilty and beheaded. The 11 years that followed witnessed a bold republican experiment that dominated the lives of those across Britain and Ireland. In this episode, Danny Bird speaks to Alice Hunt about her new book on this revolutionary chapter in history. She discusses a transformative decade which saw some of the 17th century's greatest literary and scientific minds cut their teeth, busts some myths about Cromwell's puritan cronies, and reveals how Britain’s republican decade has left an indelible mark on its modern monarchy and constitution.
(Ad) Alice Hunt is the author of Republic: Britain’s Revolutionary Decade, 1649-1660 (Faber & Faber, 2024). Buy it now from Amazon: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Republic-Britains-Revolutionary-Decade-1649-1660/dp/0571303196/?tag=bbchistory045-21&ascsubtag=historyextra-social-histboty.
Ronald Hutton answers listener questions on Cromwell’s Protectorate: https://link.chtbl.com/9rP72VAb.
The HistoryExtra podcast is produced by the team behind BBC History Magazine.