Not Another D&D Podcast D&D Court: Deadly Doors, Bland Backstories, and Strict DMs
Nov 6, 2025
In this session of Dungeon Court, Justices take on listener dilemmas, including a one-shot where a 'nothing' riddle led to disastrous consequences. They tackle the challenge of disengaged players with bland backstories, debating how DMs can encourage better player involvement. A strict DM's bizarre rules about out-of-character speech spark laughter and critique. Other dilemmas include a player’s impossible heist during Misty Step, and creative strategies for using terrain in combat. Expect plenty of advice and humorous insights!
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Set Clear Stakes And Visuals
- Describe rooms and visual aids clearly when puzzles depend on counting or noticing details.
- Warn players about lethal stakes or offer contested mechanics instead of sudden deaths.
Good Puzzles Need Good Delivery
- A great puzzle can be ruined by poor communication or DM spite.
- Killing players for theatrical shock damages future table trust and repeat business.
Coordinate Character Retirements
- Talk with players one-on-one about retirement or character changes before forcing plot moments.
- Flag upcoming opportunities to switch characters so uninterested players can opt in.