The Fifth Column #482 - Centrism Kills (w/ Josh Barro)
126 snips
Dec 12, 2024 
Josh Barro, a journalist known for his insightful analysis in independent media, joins the conversation to delve into contemporary social issues. They explore the controversial Daniel Penny verdict and its implications for mental health commitments. The discussion turns to the evolving landscape of journalism amidst the rise of platforms like Substack. Barro also addresses the challenges Democrats face with centrist perspectives and voter sentiment in a politically charged environment. Expect a mix of humor and critical reflections on the complexities of urban realities and healthcare misconceptions.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Penny and Neely Case
- Daniel Penny, a 24-year-old Marine, choked Jordan Neely, a 30-year-old homeless Michael Jackson impersonator, to death on the subway.
- Neely had a history of mental illness and assault, spending time in Rikers Island where he was reportedly stable on medication.
Challenges of Mental Illness Treatment
- Neely's history highlights the challenges of treating mental illness, especially the tension between individual liberty and public safety.
- Despite offers of services and treatment, Neely's unwillingness to consistently receive treatment led to his eventual death.
Involuntary Commitment
- Josh Barro argues that the core issue is the need for more involuntary commitment for individuals with severe mental illness.
- He believes that focusing on the specifics of the Penny verdict distracts from the larger systemic issue.
