Former head of the Mossad intelligence directorate, Zohar Palti, discusses the decision-making process in the Israel-Hamas conflict and the possibility of a breakthrough. Other topics include the controversy surrounding UNRWA's ties to Hamas, the importance of bringing hostages home, intelligence failures, Iran's involvement in the region, the Israel-America relationship, and Israeli politics.
The Israeli intelligence community faced a major embarrassment due to shortcomings in interpreting and communicating critical information.
Decision-makers in Israel balance moral considerations with the need to combat terrorism in a challenging environment.
The negotiation process for bringing hostages back home involves prioritizing the safety and security of Israeli citizens, with other considerations being secondary.
Deep dives
The Urgency to Bring Hostages Home
There is a moral obligation for Israel to bring its people back home, which has been a top priority for the government. Momentum has built up for a potential breakthrough in releasing the hostages and pausing the fighting, but emotions are high due to recent events and losses in the conflict.
Examining the Intelligence Failure
The October 7th raid exposed a major embarrassment and shame for the intelligence community in Israel. The surprise attack revealed shortcomings in intelligence interpretation and communication. Younger officers expected someone in command to recognize the danger, but this critical information was missed by those in senior positions.
Navigating Moral and Operational Challenges
Israel faces a challenging environment where moral standards must be upheld alongside the need to combat terrorism. Decision-makers in Israel have the freedom to raise moral considerations in discussions, although the country's code of morality and values already instills them. The rough neighborhood and constant threats require creative and smart approaches to counterterrorism while striving to minimize harm to civilians and protect Israeli citizens.
Negotiating the Release of Hostages
The podcast episode discusses the negotiation process and challenges involved in bringing hostages back home. The speaker emphasizes that the priority in the room is the safety and security of the Israeli people, and all other considerations are secondary. The decision-making process involves a small group of officials who have to make tough decisions and strategize how to sell and explain those decisions to the public.
The Opportunity for Peace in the Middle East
The podcast also explores the potential for peace in the region, particularly highlighting the opportunity for Israel and Saudi Arabia to normalize relations. The speaker believes that if Saudi Arabia joins the Abraham Accords and signs a peace treaty with Israel, it would send a powerful message to the region and undermine the influence of Iran. However, the speaker acknowledges that resolving the Palestinian issue is a significant challenge, as the internal Israeli problem needs to be addressed, and a political horizon is necessary for a sustainable peace process.
As hopes rise and fall of a breakthrough that would bring the release of Israeli hostages held by Hamas and a pause in fighting in Gaza, Yonit and Jonathan speak to Zohar Palti, former head of the Mossad intelligence directorate about how the key decisions are being made - and whether those in charge are getting it right. Plus: UNRWA, the meaning of the ICJ’s decision and is the Israeli far right serious about resettling Gaza?
To record a question for our next episode go to: www.speakpipe.com/unholy
*Zohar Palti is an Andrew Viterbi fellow at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy
Join Yonit Levi and Jonathan Freedland for a special night of news and surprises—live on stage, June 8th 2025. If you’ve ever wanted to see the podcast come to life, now’s your chance. Reserve your seat now via the link—space is limited, and we’d love to see you there! https://bit.ly/UnholyLondonLive
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
