Left-Wing Melancholia & the Post '67 Arab Subject with Nihal El Aasar
Dec 9, 2024
auto_awesome
Nihal El Aasar, an Egyptian writer and researcher based in London, dives into the intricate connections between the Palestinian struggle and broader anti-imperialist movements. She emphasizes the critical historical context of the 1967 defeat and its impact on Arab identity and nationalism. By referencing Palestinian intellectual Ghassan Kanafani, El Aasar critiques the narrow framing of Palestine within a larger narrative of Arab liberation. Highlighting the role of reactionary regimes, she discusses the need for solidarity and political engagement among Arab masses amidst current geopolitical tensions.
Palestine's centrality in Arab politics necessitates recognizing the interconnectedness of its struggle with broader regional issues of capitalism and imperialism.
Historical events like the 1967 defeat have profoundly influenced Arab socialism, national movements, and the ongoing political paralysis in the region.
The recent surge in protests across Arab countries reflects a growing unity and resistance against oppression, indicating a potential revival of political engagement.
Deep dives
The Importance of the Palestinian Struggle
Palestine is central to the contemporary Arab political discourse, as highlighted in the discussion surrounding the absence of Arab masses amidst Israel's actions. It is crucial to recognize that the Palestinian struggle cannot be isolated from the wider regional context involving capitalism and imperialism in the Middle East. The contributions of influential Palestinian intellectuals, particularly Ghassan Kanafani, remind us to redefine the Palestinian question to include broader Arab struggles. Failing to do this results in a narrow framing that not only diminishes the significance of Palestine but also overlooks the common political destinies shared by Arab nations.
Historical Context of Arab Political Movements
The podcast delves into the impact of historical events, such as the defeat in 1967, on Arab socialism and pan-Arabism, linking these past dynamics to present political paralysis. This defeat marked a significant moment for Arab nationalism, leading to shifts in ideologies that favored neoliberal policies and weakened national liberation movements across the region. It is essential to analyze how the actions of reactionary Arab regimes contribute to this weakening by undermining popular movements through repression and manipulation. A materialist perspective reveals that this historical context is fundamental for understanding the current state of political engagement among Arab masses.
Repression and Political Paralysis
The podcast emphasizes the role of systemic repression in creating a state of political paralysis within Arab countries, highlighting the chronic depression stemming from consistent defeat. It reflects on how the police state in countries like Egypt has expanded, silencing dissent and effectively making the masses politically inactive. With a significant portion of the population harboring feelings of melancholia regarding the failures of past movements, there is a need to confront and learn from these defeats to reactivate political engagement. By reframing defeat not as a finality but as a material reality, the path forward is opened for renewed political struggle and learning from history.
Emerging Solidarity and Resistance
Recent events following significant aggressions against Gaza have prompted a resurgence of protests and solidarity actions among Arab populations, showcasing public yearning for change. Despite severe state repression, spontaneous protests have emerged in various countries, alongside a substantial boycott movement against Western products, indicating a form of grassroots resistance. The notion of unified discourse around Palestine is gaining traction, as Arab communities seek to transcend sectarian divides and reaffirm their shared history. This reflects a growing awareness of the interconnectedness of struggles across the Arab world, pushing citizens to challenge both local and global imperialism.
Redefining Arab Political Identity
The podcast discusses the evolving political identity within the Arab world in the context of the recent wars and uprisings, focusing on contrasting past affiliations with emerging movements. In light of historical failures and current challenges, there is a critical need to create new forms of solidarity that substitute outdated concepts of political organization with more inclusive and effective systems of resistance. Reflecting on the past experiences of the Arab Spring, there is hope that new political subjects will arise, capable of addressing the socio-economic and political grievances present today. This transformation hinges on the ability to integrate lessons from past struggles into current frameworks of activism, allowing for a revived Arab political identity.
[editor's note: Due to the context of rapidly developing events in the region, it is important to note that this conversation was recorded back in early October, 2024] In this episode, we speak with Nihal El Aasar about her recently penned essay, "Left Wing Melancholia, the Arab Political Subject." We speak about Palestine's importance to the Arab political subject and the need to analyze the current absence of the Arab masses in light of Israel’s genocidal onslaught. She highlights the influence of Palestinian intellectual Ghassan Kanafani on her work, particularly his broader definition of the Palestinian question and the importance of not isolating it from the wider struggle against capitalism and imperialism in the so-called Middle East and beyond. Nihal critiques the narrow framing of the Palestinian struggle vis-a-vis Israel and stresses the need to consider the wider Arab and regional dimensions of the struggle. We also explore the role of reactionary Arab regimes play in weakening the National Liberation Movement and preying on the masses' instincts toward national and class liberation. Nihal provides historical context, discussing the impact of the 1967 defeat on Arab socialism and pan-Arabism, and the subsequent rise of neoliberal policies that have continued to govern certain segments of the region. Through a materialist lens, she critiques the current political paralysis that can be observed throughout the Arab world, attributing it to severe repression and systemic depoliticization. We cross-reference this paralysis and juxtapose the phenomenon across similar instances happening across the world—including for Black folks in the US. She emphasizes the need to grapple with defeat as a material reality and learn from past struggles to reactivate the colonized masses and reengage in political struggle. Nihal is an Egyptian writer, researcher and radio host. She mainly writes about politics, political economy and culture. Her work has appeared in various Arabic and English language publications. If you like what we do and want to support our ability to have more conversations like this. Please consider becoming a patron. You can do so for as little as a 1 Dollar a month. This episode is edited & produced by Aidan Elias. Music, as always, is by Televangel Links: "Left Wing Melancholia, the Arab Political Subject." For another related conversation on Nasser, the context of Arab regimes today, and some of the same dynamics that Nihal outlines in this conversation, we recently hosted Ameed Faleh discussing among other things Anouar Abdel-Malek’s Egypt: Military Society.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode