The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL Team tiers from Super Bowl or Bust to Mock Draft Enthusiasts
27 snips
Oct 16, 2025 As the NFL season unfolds, excitement builds with team tiers taking center stage. Discover which teams are labeled 'Super Bowl or Bust' and why they rose to the top. Delve into discussions about likely playoff contenders, while the hosts tackle fringe teams battling injuries. The breakdown of teams with good vibes, like the Bears and Giants, contrasts sharply with the underperformers facing disappointing seasons. Finally, stay tuned as they predict which teams are already eyeing the draft—it's a fun and insightful look at the league's current landscape!
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Vibes-Driven Team Evaluation
- Vibes matter: Robert Mays and Dave Helman intentionally used a “vibes-driven” approach to tier teams rather than pure metrics.
- They argue gut reads can be valuable when combined with selective data and context.
Talent Can Offset Unit Flaws
- Top-tier teams can survive glaring flaws if they possess elite quarterbacks or core talent.
- The hosts place Bills, Packers, Rams, Chiefs, Lions, and Eagles in 'Super Bowl or Bust' despite imperfections.
Read Trades As Intent Signals
- Treat organizational signals (big trades, roster moves) as commitments to win now.
- Use those moves to adjust expectations about a team’s ambition and ceiling.