
The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL
The Athletic’s flagship NFL podcast covers the league like only The Athletic can. Host Robert Mays and co-host Derrik Klassen dive into the biggest stories, break down the Xs and Os, tackle the ins and outs of roster building, follow the details of why we all love this sport, and have plenty of fun along the way, bringing the expertise necessary to cover the NFL at the highest level. Whether it’s happening on the field or behind the scenes, you’ll get an in-depth look at all things NFL on The Athletic Football Show, available wherever you get your podcasts. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Latest episodes

Jun 27, 2025 • 1h 18min
Looking backward and forward for this season's second-year quarterbacks
The podcast dives into the journeys of first-round quarterbacks in their second NFL season. It highlights the struggles and growth of players like Caleb Williams and Jaden Daniels. The hosts discuss the importance of effective coaching and how psychological factors impact performance. Listeners can expect insights on how these quarterbacks handle blitzes and grow under pressure. Comparisons between second-year stars and rookies reveal optimism for the future of the league's quarterback landscape.

10 snips
Jun 25, 2025 • 52min
The duality of NFL expectations
Explore the unpredictability of NFL team performances as hosts dissect teams that surprise us positively or negatively each season. They analyze historical trends to identify traits of overrated and underrated teams. The discussion also covers the dynamic relationship between offense and defense, revealing how player contracts and coaching can significantly impact outcomes. With fresh insights on emerging quarterbacks and the effects of short-lived successes, this episode promises to enhance your understanding of NFL expectations versus reality.

7 snips
Jun 24, 2025 • 1h 5min
Our guilty pleasure storylines
Dive into the delightful world of NFL guilty pleasures! Explore Dak Prescott's legacy and the hilarious narratives that surround it. Discover the contrasting journeys of quarterbacks like Dak and Russell, and ponder the performance of players in cold conditions. The debate over Hall of Fame candidacies adds a thought-provoking twist, while receiver dynamics and coaching futures are analyzed in a fun light. Enjoy a blend of stats and slapstick as the hosts navigate through football's quirks!

7 snips
Jun 23, 2025 • 52min
Mailbag Monday: Worst QB rooms of the past decade, Protector of the Year Award, which low-expectations teams can make the playoffs, and more
Listeners dive into the depths of NFL quarterback struggles, uncovering the worst QB rooms of the last decade, including tales of the 2017 Browns. The new Protector of the Year Award is introduced, celebrating standout offensive linemen. An intriguing discussion unfolds about low-expectation teams that might just make a playoff splash. Alongside a mix of personal anecdotes and lighthearted movie debates, the hosts explore how coaching impacts player performance and team reputations shift expectations in unexpected ways.

9 snips
Jun 20, 2025 • 1h 4min
Lingering questions, episode 4: The Steelers' non-QB shortcomings, the Bears' defensive personnel, and the Falcons' pass rush drought
The discussion dives into the overlooked strengths of the Steelers, Bears, and Falcons, examining their defensive capabilities. It questions whether Pittsburgh's issues stem solely from the quarterback position, highlighting the importance of TJ Watt. The Bears' defensive talent is assessed, considering potential upgrades from new coaching. The Falcons' struggles with pass rush are scrutinized, emphasizing the need for improvement to become competitive. Overall, it’s a deep dive into the dynamics shaping these key NFL teams.

10 snips
Jun 19, 2025 • 1h 15min
The salary cap, uncapped
Joel Corry, a former NFL agent and CBS Sports contributor, unpacks the enigmatic salary cap that governs team building in the league. He explores the significance of guaranteed money and contract structuring, shedding light on how these factors influence both player stability and team strategies. Joel also delves into cash flow management and the use of void years in contracts, illustrating their strategic advantages. The conversation highlights the complex decisions teams make in navigating the cap and maintaining competitive rosters.

17 snips
Jun 18, 2025 • 1h 36min
NFC QB supporting cast rankings
Dive into the intriguing landscape of NFC quarterback supporting casts! The hosts rank and analyze essential factors like offensive line strength and play-calling effectiveness. They debate team dynamics, focusing on the Giants and Seahawks while expressing cautious optimism for some. As they evaluate teams like the Panthers and Saints, they highlight coaching strategies and injuries that impact performance. With discussions about the Cowboys' uncertainties and the importance of continuity, it's a deep look into what makes each team tick this season!

7 snips
Jun 16, 2025 • 1h 14min
Mailbag Monday: A shifting of the QB age cliff, a longer leash for GMs, and a new occupant of the Derek Carr line
In this engaging discussion, the hosts delve into the shifting dynamics of quarterback performance and age, pondering whether the notorious age cliff is moving in the wrong direction. They consider the evolving expectations for general managers, advocating for longer leashes in their roles. A key highlight is the introduction of a new player who may take over the infamous Derek Carr line. Additionally, they explore the intricacies of assembling an ideal offensive line while weighing investments in star players versus cost-effective options.

15 snips
Jun 13, 2025 • 1h 22min
AFC QB supporting cast rankings
Explore the vital role of supporting casts around AFC quarterbacks in this lively discussion. Key teams like the Jets, Patriots, and Browns get the spotlight as hosts dissect offensive line strength and talented skill players. Discover how coaching changes can dramatically reshape team dynamics, and dive into debates on player impacts, especially with the Chiefs and Bills. The conversation heats up with insights on the unpredictability of team performance and future coaching strategies that could redefine their success.

Jun 12, 2025 • 1h 1min
Lingering questions, episode 3: The Chiefs' lack of explosiveness, Baker Mayfield's late-20s breakout, and the 49ers' relative slide on offense
The discussion tackles the current struggles of the Chiefs' offense, questioning if their explosive play can return. It also dives into Baker Mayfield's impressive late-career turnaround, exploring whether it's sustainable. The analysis then shifts to the 49ers, assessing their offensive slide beyond just injuries, and identifying potential deeper issues in their strategy. The interplay between player health and team performance is a crucial theme as they search for solutions moving forward.