From Trump to TikTok: Chris Hayes on the Rise of Attention Capitalism
Jan 23, 2025
auto_awesome
In this engaging discussion, Chris Hayes, host of "All In with Chris Hayes" on MSNBC, delves into the concept of attention capitalism, the idea that attention is our most valuable resource. He explains how figures like Trump and Musk excel in capturing attention and its implications for our politics and media. The conversation highlights the challenges journalists face in a distraction-driven world and critiques how Democrats can learn from their opponents in the battle for public engagement. Hayes urges a rethink of our digital connections amidst growing frustrations with tech giants.
Chris Hayes emphasizes that the relentless distraction from smartphones has diminished our ability to engage meaningfully with our thoughts and experiences.
The podcast explores how politicians like Trump and Musk effectively manipulate attention dynamics for personal gain, contrasting with traditional political strategies.
Hayes advocates for grassroots movements to create non-commercial alternatives to mainstream digital platforms in order to reclaim authentic human connections.
Deep dives
The Overwhelming Nature of Attention
We live in an era where continuous distractions from smartphones dominate our focus, as emphasized by Chris Hayes. He explains that the excessive amount of information we encounter every day makes it challenging to discern what truly deserves our attention. This situation is likened to the sirens in the Odyssey, as our devices lure us into a constant cycle of checking notifications and updates, often leading to feelings of addiction. As these distractions proliferate, Hayes argues that they detract from our ability to engage with more meaningful aspects of life.
The Extractive Nature of Attention
Hayes discusses how tech companies are essentially extracting our attention for profit, operating as modern-day information thieves. He asserts that attention has now become the most valuable resource, likening its importance to an addiction where users are compelled to scroll endlessly despite knowing it may not be beneficial. This extraction not only affects our individual experiences but symbolizes a broader societal issue, as people's essential life moments become commodified for corporate gain. The quest for attention becomes zero-sum, where one entity’s gain is often at the expense of another's focus.
Impact on Human Experience
The discussion highlights the existential effects of constant smartphone use, particularly how it disrupts fundamental human qualities such as introspection and contemplation. Hayes posits that engaging deeply with our thoughts has diminished, leading to a cultural aversion to boredom. He ties this back to a historical philosophical context, referencing figures like the Buddha and Pascal who acknowledged the difficulty of embracing solitude and stillness. The pervasive nature of modern technology amplifies this struggle, making it more challenging for individuals to engage meaningfully with their own internal dialogues.
The Role of Politics in the Attention Economy
Hayes points out how politicians have leveraged the dynamics of the attention economy, particularly citing Donald Trump's ability to secure attention through negative engagement. This contrasts with traditional political strategies that sought broader appeal and positive attention. The failure of many Democratic politicians to adapt to this new reality often results in a lack of resonance with potential voters. By analyzing effective figures like AOC, Hayes suggests that embracing authentic, sometimes controversial, ways to capture attention can yield more successful political engagement.
Possible Solutions and Backlash
Amid the persistent focus on maximizing attention extraction, Hayes advocates for a backlash against this system through grassroots movements and legislative changes. He describes the potential for creating non-commercial alternatives to the mainstream digital landscape, drawing parallels with historical shifts in food culture that resulted in organic movements. Additionally, he discusses the emergence of new communication methods that prioritize genuine connections devoid of commercial motives. Hayes envisions a future where people actively seek to reclaim their attention in a manner that fosters authentic human relationships and experiences.
Attention is our world’s most endangered resource — and whoever commands it, commands power. That’s the thesis of Chris Hayes’s new book, The Sirens’ Call, which chronicles the rise of attention capitalism and how it’s fundamentally disordering our politics, our media, and our brains. It’s a book Hayes felt partly inspired to write after years covering President Trump, an unparalleled expert in manipulating this attention age. Well, unparalleled until Elon Musk. Kara and Chris discuss how "big tech" got us here, what makes Trump and Musk so good at commanding attention, and whether Democrats should figure out how to command more attention themselves.
Questions? Comments? Email us at on@voxmedia.com or find us on Instagram and TikTok @onwithkaraswisher
