Daniel Hagler and Aryeh Englander: Can Jews Who Stay Talk With Jews Who Left? [OTD 2/4]

May 27, 2025

Daniel Hagler, a trauma surgeon and active participant in religious debates, joins Aryeh Englander, a former Orthodox Jew and moderator of a dialogue group. Together, they dive into the complexities of Judaism, discussing how faith transcends mere evidence and the importance of personal journeys. Their conversation explores the balance between pragmatism and belief, the significance of meaningful dialogue within the community, and the evolving nature of faith in a modern context, inviting listeners to engage with their understanding of truth and identity.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Books

Transcript

Episode notes

INSIGHT

Religious Commitment as Relationship

Religious commitment is more like relationships than binary truths.
It reflects our whole self beyond mere data points or proofs.

INSIGHT

Shared Data, Different Methodologies

Both Aryeh and Daniel agree they access the same data but interpret it differently.
Their core difference lies in how they apply epistemological methods to that data.

INSIGHT

Pragmatism vs. Accuracy in Belief

Daniel sees belief in God as pragmatically useful despite uncertain evidence.
Aryeh prioritizes evidence accuracy, not pragmatic benefit, in belief formation.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

How Judaism Became a Religion

Leora Batnitzky

Jewish Philosophy As a Guide to Life

Hilary Putnam

Judaism on Trial

Jewish-Christian Disputations in the Middle Ages

Hyam Maccoby

Notes from Underground

null

Fyodor Dostoevsky

Fyodor Dostoevsky's "Notes from Underground" is a novella that delves into the mind of an unnamed narrator, a bitter and alienated individual who rails against reason and societal norms. The work is considered a precursor to existentialist literature, exploring themes of isolation, nihilism, and the human condition. Dostoevsky's masterful use of first-person narration allows readers to experience the narrator's turbulent thoughts and emotions. The novella's exploration of free will and the complexities of human psychology continues to resonate with readers today. Its influence on literature and philosophy is undeniable, shaping the works of later writers and thinkers.

A Letter in the Scroll

Radical Then Radical Now

Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks

Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks' "A Letter in the Scroll" delves into the core principles of Judaism, exploring its timeless relevance in the modern world. The book examines the enduring power of Jewish tradition and its capacity to guide individuals and communities through contemporary challenges. Sacks masterfully weaves together theological insights, philosophical reflections, and historical analysis to illuminate the essence of Jewish identity and purpose. He emphasizes the importance of maintaining a strong connection to Jewish heritage while engaging with the broader world. The book serves as a powerful testament to the enduring strength and relevance of Judaism in a rapidly changing world.

Reality+

Virtual Worlds and the Problems of Philosophy

David Chalmers

In 'Reality+: Virtual Worlds and the Problems of Philosophy', David J. Chalmers conducts a comprehensive analysis of the intersection between virtual reality, philosophy, and science. He argues that virtual worlds are not inferior to physical reality and that we can lead meaningful lives within them. The book addresses various philosophical questions, such as the nature of reality, the relation between mind and body, and the possibility of being in a simulated world. Chalmers uses virtual reality technology to offer new perspectives on long-standing philosophical issues, making the book a significant contribution to the fields of philosophy, science, and technology.