Adam Grant, an organizational psychologist and author at the Wharton School, delves into pressing post-election topics. He explores how to navigate post-election anxiety and the complexities of trusting experts in today's media landscape. The conversation highlights the psychological effects of political events and discusses the dangers of empathic overload. Grant also challenges the concept of meritocracy in success measurement and advocates for balanced media consumption to mitigate emotional distress.
Historical context can help mitigate post-election anxiety by reminding us that emotional reactions to political events often diminish quickly.
Experts in stable fields may deserve our trust, but experts in dynamic areas like politics often provide uncertain predictions we should scrutinize.
Fostering compassion rather than empathy allows for constructive responses to social issues and helps maintain better mental well-being.
Deep dives
Reframing Uncertainty
The discussion emphasizes the need to reframe our perception of uncertainty, particularly in light of recent political events. Adam Grant suggests that while many may feel overwhelmed and fearful about the future, history shows that assumptions about calamities are often exaggerated. He highlights the tendency of humans to overestimate how bad things will become, noting that even political experts can make inaccurate forecasts. The historical context offers lessons that can help in mitigating the dread associated with uncertain times, allowing individuals to adopt a more balanced outlook on future events.
Trusting Experts: A Nuanced Approach
The conversation dives into the complex relationship between the public and experts, emphasizing that while expert knowledge is valuable, expert predictions may often fall short. Grant introduces the distinction between stable and dynamic environments, contending that experts in stable contexts, like medicine, deserve our trust compared to those in rapidly changing areas, such as politics. For instance, he points to a study demonstrating that highly regarded experts often perform no better than chance when predicting uncertain outcomes. This acknowledgment urges a critical reassessment of when to rely on experts and how confidently we should embrace their forecasts.
The Effects of Political Outcomes
Grant reflects on the psychological impact of political outcomes on individuals, particularly around the recent elections. He notes that often people overstate the long-term effects of losing an election, as historical data shows that emotional reactions tend to be temporary rather than enduring. By analyzing trends post-elections, he points out that many voters quickly return to their baseline emotional states within weeks, suggesting resilience and adaptability amidst political turbulence. This insight serves as a reminder that while political events can feel monumental, their emotional toll may diminish more swiftly than anticipated.
Challenges of Compassion versus Empathy
The podcast explores the critical difference between compassion and empathy, which can profoundly impact interpersonal connections and societal engagement. Grant describes empathy as the act of feeling another's emotions, which can sometimes lead to overwhelm and disengagement from those in distress. In contrast, compassion encourages action by focusing on alleviating another's suffering without becoming immobilized by shared pain. This understanding suggests that fostering compassion rather than empathy may lead to more constructive responses to social issues and improve mental well-being.
Cultivating Diverse Interests for Well-being
The importance of diversifying personal interests as a coping strategy is a central theme, highlighting how this approach can buffer against stress. Grant argues that by engaging in varied activities—beyond politics or work—individuals can foster resilience and improve overall life satisfaction. He stresses that cultivating multiple identities and interests can provide a safety net, allowing one to navigate personal challenges without becoming overly fixated on any single aspect of life. This diversified approach not only promotes mental health but can also lead to more meaningful and fulfilling experiences.
Adam Grant is an organizational psychologist and author who teaches at the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania. He joins Preet to discuss:
After the election, our work making sense of legal news continues. For the month of November, visit cafe.com/november to get 40% off your membership for the first year.
Have a question for Preet? Ask @PreetBharara on Threads, or Twitter with the hashtag #AskPreet. Email us at staytuned@cafe.com, or call 669-247-7338 to leave a voicemail.
Stay Tuned with Preet is brought to you by CAFE and the Vox Media Podcast Network.