Accusations of bias over media commentary on the national hui at Tūrangawaewae marae. Media response to the downfall of Green MP Golriz Gharahman. Controversial opinion pieces by Mihi Forbes and John Campbell. Political situation for Mardi and grievances over decisions affecting Mardi health and the treaty. Controversy and criticism of John Campbell's articles. Impact of social media on freedom of speech and online abuse. Relationship between mental health and political scandals.
The media's coverage of the national hui at Tūrangawaewae marae drew criticism for displaying an optimistic tone, leading some to question objectivity and impartiality.
Journalists can hold opinions while maintaining fair reporting, as long as opinions are expressed fairly and balanced reporting is maintained.
Deep dives
Coverage and Opinions on the Hui at Naru Awaika
The coverage and opinions on the Hui at Naru Awaika have sparked controversy and comment. One piece by Aaron Smail for newsroom provides a detailed account of the history and tensions surrounding the event, relating it to the present day. Mihi Forbes' RNZ piece and John Campbell's TVNZ piece focus on the unity and hope at the Hui, despite the background discontent with the government. The optimistic tone of these pieces drew criticism from some, questioning objectivity and impartiality.
Addressing Opinions in Journalism
The debate around expressing opinions in journalism arose in response to John Campbell's opinion piece. Some argued for his sacking, accusing him of bias and a failure of objectivity. However, it is contended that journalists can hold opinions while remaining fair brokers in their reporting. Calls for complete neutrality are seen as unsustainable, as long as opinions are expressed fairly and balanced reporting is maintained.
Media Coverage of Politicians and Mental Health
The media's handling of politicians' shoplifting allegations, such as Golriz Ghahraman's case, has spurred criticism. Balancing coverage and mental health issues is a challenge, as the media needs to address both the story and the mental well-being of individuals. Mental health as an explanation for actions in politics can be viewed with skepticism, but it is crucial to remember that mental health is a genuine concern that affects many individuals. Striking a balance between accountability and empathy is necessary in media coverage.
Hayden Donnell talks to Emile Donovan about accusations of bias over media commentary on the national hui at Tūrangawaewae marae and the media response to the downfall of Green MP Golriz Gharahman.
In this week's edition of Midweek Mediawatch, Hayden Donnell talks to Emile Donovan about accusations of bias over media commentary on the national hui at Tūrangawaewae marae - and media response to the downfall of Green MP Golriz Gharahman.