BABE: PIG IN THE CITY — George Miller makes one for the grownups
Nov 21, 2024
auto_awesome
James Cromwell, known for his role as Farmer Hoggett in the beloved Babe films and his recent work in HBO's Succession, joins the discussion to explore the striking tonal shift in Babe: Pig in the City. The conversation dives into the unexpected darker themes of the sequel, reflecting George Miller's creative risks and his background as a doctor. Cromwell shares behind-the-scenes insights on training over 700 animals for the film, and the challenges faced while appealing to both children and adults in a story filled with emotional depth.
George Miller's darker vision for Babe: Pig in the City aimed to portray life's harsh realities, drastically diverging from the original's tone.
The sequel's box office failure highlighted the risks filmmakers face when challenging audience expectations in family-oriented narratives.
Deep dives
The Unexpected Success of Babe
The film Babe debuted in 1995, surprising audiences and critics alike with its heartfelt story and innovative effects, making it a box office success against all expectations. Based on a children's book about a talking pig who becomes a sheepdog, it garnered positive reviews and a cult following that propelled it to over $120 million in earnings. The film's unexpected blockbuster status caught Universal Pictures off guard, and it went on to receive critical acclaim, winning a Golden Globe and even a Best Picture nomination. Its charm not only captivated families but also sparked conversations about animal ethics, influencing some viewers to adopt vegetarian lifestyles.
The Ill-Fated Sequel: Babe, Pig in the City
The sequel, Babe, Pig in the City, released in 1998, starkly contrasted with the original's warm reception, offering a darker narrative that shocked audiences. Directed by George Miller, who sought to impose a more serious tone, the film's plot involved distressing events like the almost fatal accident of Farmer Hoggett and a chaotic adventure in a rough city that alienated the intended family audience. This shift towards a grim portrayal left viewers traumatized, leading to many families walking out of theaters, confused by the unexpected darkness compared to the lighthearted first film. Despite critical praise from notable reviewers, the box office performance suffered significantly, earning only $69 million against its $90 million budget.
Behind the Dark Humor: George Miller's Vision
Miller's unique vision for Babe, Pig in the City stemmed from his background as an emergency room doctor, which revealed the harsh realities of life that he wanted to portray through the film's narrative. The movie's script included themes of violence and existential despair that diverged sharply from the cheerful tone of the original. Miller's intent was to explore deeper societal issues through the innocent perspective of Babe, reflecting his belief that a kind heart could navigate a cruel world. The dark and surreal elements woven into the story prompted discussions on whether this approach was suitable for children, showcasing Miller's desire to challenge audience expectations.
Industry Impact and Miller's Career Aftermath
The stark differences between Babe and its sequel prompted significant fallout within Universal Pictures, leading to major personnel changes after the film's disappointing performance. The backlash against Babe, Pig in the City also impacted George Miller's career trajectory, as he did not direct another film for eight years, choosing to reflect on the lessons learned from this experience. Though he eventually returned to children's cinema with Happy Feet, the sequel again faced mixed reception, showcasing the unpredictable nature of pursuing innovative narratives in traditional genres. Miller's commitment to authentic storytelling continues to shape his projects, even as he navigates the challenges of commercial success in Hollywood.
The first BABE was a family-friendly megahit. So for the sequel, why did director George Miller thrust his sweet porcine hero into a family-unfriendly nightmare? Host Rico Gagliano takes a trot down the mean streets of BABE: PIG IN THE CITY, telling the story of its rise and box-office fall with the help of guests including Farmer Hoggett himself, James Cromwell (SUCCESSION), and voice-of-Babe E.G. Daily (PEE-WEE’S BIG ADVENTURE).
The latest season of The MUBI Podcast – BOX OFFICE POISON — dives into six visionary films... that were also notorious flops. Inspired by the new book of the same name by Tim Robey, film critic for The Telegraph, every episode is a wild ride through a great movie's rise, and fall, and rise.
The Short Films Big Namescollection is now streaming on MUBI. To watch some of the films we've covered on the podcast, check out the collection Featured on the MUBI Podcast. Availability of films varies depending on your country.
MUBI is a global streaming service, production company and film distributor dedicated to elevating great cinema. MUBI makes, acquires, curates, and champions extraordinary films, connecting them to audiences all over the world. A place to discover ambitious new films and singular voices, from iconic directors to emerging auteurs. Each carefully chosen by MUBI’s curators.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode