Abigail Tracy and John Harwood discuss Kevin McCarthy's failure to control the House GOP caucus as a government shutdown looms. Harwood criticizes bombthrowers like Gaetz, Greene, and Boebert for not being serious politicians. The podcast explores the impact of a shutdown on government employees and the motivations behind the impeachment inquiry into President Biden. It also delves into the role of the press, challenges in political debates, and upcoming events.
Bombthrowers like Matt Gaetz, Marjorie Taylor Greene, and Lauren Boebert are not serious people and lack the ability to make government work.
The current Republican Party's focus on ego gratification and their inability to compromise or govern leads to a government shutdown.
Deep dives
Reasons for Government Shutdown
The current Republican Party, particularly its angriest factions, is not built to govern in the modern world. There is no coherent approach to budget issues and a lack of realism about the real budget issues. Instead, they focus on narrow parts of the budget that oppose the country's adaptation to the modern world. This intense opposition to the changing landscape drives them to disrupt and obstruct governance, leading to a government shutdown.
Rogue Republicans and the Shutdown
A small group of rogue Republicans is fueling the government shutdown and seem indifferent to the detrimental consequences it will have on average people, even when confronted with their suffering in calls from government employees who will struggle to pay their bills. This group of Republicans lacks clear goals or demands, continuously shifting their demands without any indication of satisfaction. Their resistance to compromise and their refusal to legislate or govern contributes to the inevitability of a government shutdown.
Accountability and the Shutdown
While there is a form of accountability for these politicians through elections and potential backlash from their leadership, their districts, which favor their extreme ideologies, render them immune to being kicked out by voters. The shutdown exposes the Republican Party's fundamental inability to govern and make trade-offs necessary for practical decision-making. The party's focus on ego gratification, rather than responsible governance, means that they are ill-equipped to address budget issues or navigate the complexities of compromising with differing viewpoints.
Host Brian Stelter talks to Vanity Fair’s Abigail Tracy and veteran political journalist John Harwood about Kevin McCarthy’s failure to control his House GOP caucus as a government shutdown looms. Bombthrowers like Matt Gaetz, Marjorie Taylor Greene, and Lauren Boebert are “not serious people,” says Harwood, a Polis Distinguished Fellow at Duke University. “They're on television, they have podcasts or whatever,” he adds, “but they're not built to do what politicians have to do to make government work.”