The Edition: Tory wars, the reality of trail hunting & is Sally Rooney-mania over?
Sep 26, 2024
auto_awesome
Ruth Porter, a Conservative peer and former leadership campaign manager for Liz Truss, joins to discuss the current state of the Tory leadership race and potential behind-the-scenes tactics ahead of the conference. The conversation addresses the complexities of selection and voting within the party. Additionally, a heated debate revolves around trail hunting, balancing tradition with ethical concerns. Finally, the discussion critically examines Sally Rooney's latest novel, exploring its reception and the evolution of her literary voice.
The podcast analyzes diverse strategies from Conservative leadership candidates, highlighting the need for effective bridging between MPs and party members.
A heated debate on trail hunting underscores the complex legislative challenges and differing perspectives on tradition versus public safety concerns.
Deep dives
Analysis of Conservative Leadership Candidates
The podcast examines the four candidates competing for the Conservative Party leadership and highlights their unique pitches. Robert Jenrick positions himself as a hardliner against immigration, advocating for leaving the European Convention on Human Rights to impose stricter controls. Kemi Badenoch presents herself as a truth-teller, focusing on conservative principles without getting bogged down in specific policy details. James Cleverley emphasizes his experience and readiness to lead, while Tom Tugenhart seeks to build party unity, signaling diverse strategic approaches among the candidates.
The Divisive Dynamics of Party Politics
A significant discussion revolves around the rift between Conservative MPs and party membership, which has deepened over recent years. The podcast suggests that this division complicates leadership campaigns, as MPs often support candidates perceived as winning the election rather than those aligned with the grassroots. Historical examples illustrate how member choices, like the rise and fall of Boris Johnson and Liz Truss, have at times contrasted sharply with MP decisions. This growing disconnect raises concerns over whether the leadership candidates can effectively unify the party and regain trust from both sides.
Operational Tactics During Leadership Campaigns
The conversation delves into the tactical intricacies of running a leadership campaign within the Conservative Party. The early phase focuses on securing MP endorsements to ascend to the final two candidates, while the latter phase involves reaching and swaying party members directly. Campaign logistics, including event scheduling and expenditure caps, become crucial in this phase, with the risk of overlooking member preferences highlighted. The discussion emphasizes the need for candidates to not only navigate these logistics but also connect meaningfully with party members to gain their support.
The Future of Trail Hunting
The podcast debates the future of trail hunting amid increasing scrutiny and calls for a ban, with trail hunting seen as a method to continue traditional hunting practices. Advocates argue that trail hunting can be bloodless, mimicking the rhythm of pre-ban hunting, while opponents raise concerns over safety and animal welfare, citing incidents of hunting hounds posing risks to the public. The discussion reveals the complexities surrounding this practice and the legislative challenges faced by the Labour Party as they consider banning trail hunting. Questions about the effectiveness of existing hunting regulations and their enforcement are also raised, spotlighting a contentious issue in rural politics.
This week: who’s on top in the Conservative leadership race?
That’s the question Katy Balls asks in the magazine this week as she looks ahead to the Conservative Party conference. Each Tory hopeful will be pitching for the support of MPs and the party faithful ahead of the next round of voting. Who’s got the most to lose, and could there be some sneaky tactics behind the scenes? Katy joins the podcast to discuss, alongside Conservative peer Ruth Porter, who ran Liz Truss’s leadership campaign in 2022. We also include an excerpt from the hustings that Katy conducted with each of the candidates earlier this week. You can find the full interviews on The Spectator’s YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/@SpectatorTV (02:07)
Next: should trail hunting be banned? Flora Watkins concedes that the hunting community has not helped its case over the years when considering the future of the sport. However, she argues that a minority should not spoil a sport that is ‘thrilling, sociable and bloodless’. In a heated discussion, Flora joins the podcast to make her case with campaigner Dominic Dyer. (17:43)
And finally: what to make of Sally Rooney’s new novel Intermezzo? In the magazine this week Claire Lowdon argues that the novel is an ‘enjoyable old-fashioned love story… but high literature it is not’. Why? Reviewing the book for the Times James Marriott argues Rooney’s characters are ‘sensitive’ but also too ‘precious and prissy’. How warranted is the criticism of Rooney? Claire and James join the pod. (31:50)
Hosted by William Moore and Gus Carter.
Produced by Oscar Edmondson and Patrick Gibbons.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode