Kristen Ghodsee, an ethnographer and author of Everyday Utopia, joins Dan to discuss Pythagoras' utopia and other attempts at creating paradise throughout history, including gender equality and communal property. They also explore the dualist belief system of the Bogomiles, its influence on the Albigensian Crusade, and the potential for reorganizing life on other planets based on historical experiments.
Pythagoras established a commune in Croton, Italy, where property was shared in common and women had equal status, challenging mainstream Greek society and laying the foundation for future utopian ideals.
The Bogomils, a religious group from the 9th-10th century, aimed for spiritual enlightenment by rejecting the material world and embracing gender equality, influencing later spiritual movements and contributing to the development of utopian thought.
Deep dives
The Origins of Utopias: Pythagoras and Communal Living
The history of utopias dates back centuries, with various attempts to create alternative societies that challenge economic inequality and hierarchical rule. One such example is Pythagoras, known for his mathematical theorem, but also as an early pioneer of utopia. Pythagoras established a commune in Croton, Italy, where property was shared in common and women had equal status. They lived as a community, eating meals together and raising children communally. This radical way of living challenged mainstream Greek society and laid the foundation for future utopian ideals.
The Bogomils: A Unique Spiritual Utopia
The Bogomils were a 9th-10th century religious group, viewed as asexual, vegan anarchists. They believed in dualism, where the material world was considered the work of the devil. In their community, men and women were equal, and women could become spiritual leaders. They aimed to achieve spiritual enlightenment and viewed the material world as a prison for their anguished spirits. The Bogomils faced persecution from the Catholic Church and were eventually exterminated. However, their influence on later spiritual movements, such as the Cathars and Albigensians, contributed to the development of utopian thought and possibly even the Protestant Reformation.
The Significance of Utopian Communities
Utopian communities, whether secular or spiritual, share common features that challenge mainstream societal norms. They prioritize shared property, communal living, and collective child-rearing. These communities deviate from the prevailing ideals of private wealth accumulation and nuclear families. Utopian communities foster cooperation, connection, and inclusivity, providing alternatives to isolation and inequality. Despite often being met with opposition and violence, utopian communities persist throughout history, offering valuable lessons for present-day societies.
Utopias and the Future of Space Settlements
As humans contemplate settling on other celestial bodies like Mars or the Moon, the organization of these future colonies becomes crucial. The history of utopias offers insights into alternative ways of living that challenge the dominant models on Earth. Given the physical and psychological challenges of space settlements, such as increased stress and reduced efficiency, communal living and strong social bonds become essential for human thriving. By studying historical utopian communities, we can envision more harmonious and sustainable ways of living together in outer space.
What comes to your mind when you think of Pythagoras, the ancient Greek polymath? Some might think of the Pythagorean theorem, a foundational principle of mathematics. But he was also the enigmatic founder of Pythagoreanism, a mysterious secret society that strove to create a utopia on earth.
Today Dan is joined by Kristen Ghodsee, an ethnographer and author of Everyday Utopia. Kristen delves into this ancient social experiment, and talks about other attempts at paradise in the millennia since.
Produced by Mariana Des Forges and James Hickmann, and edited by Ella Blaxill.
Discover the past with exclusive history documentaries and ad-free podcasts presented by world-renowned historians from History Hit. Watch them on your smart TV or on the go with your mobile device. Get 50% off your first 3 months with code DANSNOW sign up now for your 14-day free trial.