Former professional football referee, Howard Webb, joins the boys to discuss VAR decisions, players as referees, and the existence of big club bias. They also analyze Manchester United's vulnerabilities and reflect on controversial VAR decisions, and discuss the challenges of implementing VAR in football.
Improving communication between officials and fans is crucial for enhancing transparency in VAR decisions.
The inclusion of former footballers in the VAR team could bring diverse expertise and address fan concerns effectively.
Deep dives
The Lionesses' Journey to the World Cup Final
The podcast discusses the success of the England women's national football team, the Lionesses, reaching the World Cup final. The hosts praise their achievements, highlighting the team's improvement throughout the tournament and the outstanding performances of key players such as Lauren James and the defensive trio of Greenwood, Bry, and Carter. The overall positive atmosphere and the strategic approach of coach Serena Vigman are emphasized. The hosts also speculate on potential team changes for the final and express confidence in the Lionesses' ability to win.
Manchester City's Performance and Challenges
The podcast addresses the current state of Manchester City's team, noting their recent triumph in the Super Cup but also highlighting concerns about their form and midfield cohesion following the departure of some key players. The performance of Cole Palmer is commended, and thoughts about his future in the team are shared. The hosts discuss the challenge of filling the void left by Kevin De Bruyne's injury and reflect on the need for creativity in the squad. They also briefly touch on Manchester United's performance against Wolves and Wolves' struggles in finishing scoring opportunities.
VAR Controversies and the Role of Howard Webb
The podcast engages in a conversation with Howard Webb, the Chief Refereeing Officer, about the use of VAR and recent controversies in its implementation. Webb discusses the need for accuracy over speed and the challenges faced by officials, including potential bias and the pressure to make quick decisions. He addresses the handball law and expresses the importance of referees being able to determine deliberate handballs. Additionally, Webb acknowledges the necessity of improving communication between officials and fans, both in the stadium and through broadcasting, to enhance understanding and transparency.
Improving VAR and Addressing Fan Concerns
The podcast concludes with a discussion on the future of VAR and efforts to address fan concerns. The potential inclusion of former footballers in the VAR team is mentioned, as well as the need for more diverse expertise in officiating. The hosts express the desire for clearer and quicker communication of VAR decisions during matches to keep fans informed. They highlight the importance of balancing accuracy and efficiency in VAR implementation to maintain the integrity and fairness of the game.
Will the fans ever get to hear what’s going on with VAR decisions? Should ex-players be helping referees? And is there really a ‘big club’ bias?
The boys are joined by Howard Webb to discuss all matters referees and VAR. Howard also finally apologises to Alan for his decision that helped relegate Newcastle back in 2009.