The McShay Show SEC Championship Reactions: Kirby’s Best Coaching Job, Bama’s Bad Day, Ty Simpson’s Future, and More
Dec 7, 2025
In this discussion, college football analyst Steve Muench shares his insights following Georgia's victory over Alabama in the SEC Championship. They dive into Alabama's disappointing performance and explore potential internal issues. Muench praises Kirby Smart for his coaching excellence. They ponder Georgia's playoff ranking and debate Alabama's chances of still making the CFP. The conversation even touches on the possible impact of the loss on Ty Simpson's draft decisions, emphasizing the need for him to refine his skills further.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Georgia Peaked Under Kirby Smart
- Georgia showed clear weekly improvement and peaked at the right time for the SEC title game.
- Todd McShay calls it possibly Kirby Smart's best coaching job, emphasizing coached depth over star power.
Alabama's Performance Raised Red Flags
- Alabama's offensive ineptitude and long time on field raised questions about internal issues.
- McShay and the crew discussed rumors about DeBoer's long-term fit amid fan discontent and speculation.
DeBoer Has Track Record But Faces Scrutiny
- Alabama's offensive coaching staff includes proven hires like Kalen DeBoer and Ryan Grubb, but fit questions persist.
- Steve Muench emphasizes DeBoer's track record while acknowledging fan impatience post-Saban.