Victor Haghani, the Founder and CIO of Elm Partners, dives deep into the volatile world of leveraged ETFs, particularly those tied to MicroStrategy and Bitcoin. He discusses the staggering risk investors face with products like MSTU and MSTX, detailing scenarios of potential massive losses. The conversation also explores the intricate relationship between MicroStrategy’s premium and Bitcoin prices. Haghani touches on new financial products targeting innovative strategies, making a compelling case for careful consideration in today’s high-risk trading landscape.
Leveraged ETFs, while designed for amplifying returns, carry substantial risks that can lead to significant losses during volatile market conditions.
MicroStrategy's significant Bitcoin holdings create a unique correlation between its stock price and Bitcoin's market movements, influencing the performance of its leveraged ETFs.
The introduction of innovative ETFs targeting long/short positions highlights the complexity of investment strategies that necessitate a deep understanding of associated risks.
Deep dives
Understanding Leveraged ETFs
Leveraged ETFs are designed to amplify the returns of the underlying assets by using borrowed funds, providing investors with a potential for higher gains. However, their inherent risk is substantial, especially amidst high volatility, as seen in recent discussions surrounding MicroStrategy's leveraged ETFs. These products are particularly sensitive to rapid price swings, which can result in significant losses if the underlying stock declines sharply. Investors are urged to approach these instruments cautiously, as their long-term return patterns can deviate from initial expectations, especially when volatility spikes.
MicroStrategy and Bitcoin Correlation
MicroStrategy has positioned itself as a significant player in the Bitcoin space, acquiring substantial amounts of the cryptocurrency. This relationship establishes a unique dynamic, where the stock's price tends to fluctuate in correlation with Bitcoin's market movements. As Bitcoin's volatility increases, significantly affecting MicroStrategy's stock price, the implications for its leveraged ETFs become profound, leading to potential large-scale financial consequences. Investors need to monitor trends closely, as a decline in Bitcoin prices could exacerbate losses on these leveraged products.
The Mechanics of Leveraged Positions
In leveraged ETFs, for every dollar invested, the fund typically holds double the amount in underlying stocks, necessitating daily rebalancing to maintain that leverage. Market movements can dramatically alter the amount of stocks held and the fund's required positions, leading to potential liquidity issues and greater market impact. This daily rebalancing can result in a high degree of volatility and unexpected performance, especially when markets are trending sharply in either direction. Understanding these mechanics helps investors grasp why holding leveraged ETFs for extended periods can lead to suboptimal returns.
Risks Associated with High Volatility
The potential for extreme volatility poses a significant risk for leveraged ETFs, particularly in relation to MicroStrategy and its tied exposure to Bitcoin. Instances of large fluctuations can trigger extensive loss, with some estimates suggesting up to a 50% decline in value may lead to catastrophic consequences for investors. The volatility inherent in Bitcoin can further complicate the financial landscape for these ETFs, resulting in complex pricing models that may be difficult for average investors to comprehend. Consequently, the prospect of losing substantial value rapidly amplifies the importance of risk management strategies.
Evolving Financial Products and Their Implications
The development of new financial products, such as innovative ETFs that employ unique strategies, underscores the growing complexity of the investment landscape. Recent initiatives propose structure changes that allow for long and short positions simultaneously, enhancing the tools available to manage investment risk. However, such products require a thorough understanding from investors to navigate the inherent risks, particularly around volatility and market behavior. As the landscape evolves, maintaining clarity around these offerings is crucial for ensuring informed investment decisions.
It was a pleasure to welcome Victor Haghani, the Founder and CIO of Elm Wealth Management back to the Alpha Exchange for an engaging discussion on those turbo-charged financial products called leveraged ETFs. Our conversation is focused on the large product suite built around MicroStrategy, a software company whose mission appears to be solely focused on the accumulation of bitcoin. Itself a stock realizing 75 to 150 vol, MSTRs two times daily return products – MSTU and MSTX – have experienced one month delivered volatility levels approaching 400.
Victor shares the recent work he and team have done to model scenarios for these products based on price and vol assumptions for MSTR. The punchline is that investors need to carefully consider the risk exposure they are getting and be prepared for potentially large losses should the underlying stock fall and volatility rise. In the course of our discussion, we contemplate the directionality of the MSTR premium to its holdings of bitcoin and whether that is itself linked to the price of bitcoin.
Lastly, we touch on a new product proposed by ETF provider Battleshares that targets a daily long/short exposure to two assets, for which the Elm team has built a model and posted on their website. I hope you enjoy this episode of the Alpha Exchange, my conversation with Victor Haghani.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode