In this enlightening discussion, Iain McGilchrist, a philosopher and neuroscientist; Beatrix Campbell, a socialist and feminist writer; and Simon Blackburn, a prominent philosopher, explore the limitations of logic in our lives. They argue that embracing irrationality can lead to a richer understanding of human experience. The conversation highlights how over-reliance on rationality can obscure personal growth and the complexities of human relationships. They assert that meaningful connections and embracing uncertainty are essential for true happiness.
43:28
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
menu_book Books
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
insights INSIGHT
Why Embracing the Irrational is Vital for Wisdom and Politics
Logic is an important tool for consistency but it cannot explain or encompass all of life’s truths, especially those involving intuition, experience, and human complexity. Iain McGilchrist argues that reason has limits and contrasts two kinds of reason: "Verstand" (rule-based logic) and "Vernunft" (wise, experience-based judgment).
Political and personal life often require embracing contradictions, ambiguity, and the unsayable like trauma and subordination, which do not fit neatly into logical frameworks. Beatrix Campbell highlights that political struggles involve contingent, lived realities that aren’t always logical or consistent.
Simon Blackburn emphasizes that while consistency in logic is critical, discovery and transformation often come from intuition and creativity beyond logic. All agree that rationality cannot fully capture the nuances of human experience or the social and emotional aspects that matter most.
insights INSIGHT
Logic's Place and Limits
Logic is a crucial tool for consistency but cannot address all aspects of reality or ultimate truths.
Intuition, guided by experience, complements reason in understanding life.
insights INSIGHT
Consistency as Logic's Core
Consistency is key to logical coherence; contradictions signal flaws needing revision.
Logic ensures internal coherence but does not generate new discoveries or handle empirical knowledge.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Karl Popper's "The Logic of Scientific Discovery" is a highly influential work in the philosophy of science. It critiques the traditional view of scientific method as inductive, arguing instead that scientific knowledge is developed through a process of conjecture and refutation. Popper introduces the concept of falsifiability, suggesting that a scientific theory must be testable and potentially falsifiable to be considered scientific. The book has had a profound impact on the philosophy of science, influencing the way scientists approach the development and testing of theories. It remains a cornerstone of modern epistemology.
The master and his emissary
The Divided Brain and the Making of the Western World
Iain McGilchrist
This book argues that the division of the brain into two hemispheres is essential to human existence, allowing for two incompatible versions of the world. The left hemisphere is detail-oriented, prefers mechanisms to living things, and is inclined to self-interest, while the right hemisphere has greater breadth, flexibility, and generosity. McGilchrist takes the reader on a journey through the history of Western culture, illustrating the tension between these two worlds as revealed in the thought and belief of thinkers and artists from ancient to modern times. He argues that the increasing dominance of the left hemisphere in today’s world has potentially disastrous consequences.
Mirror Mirror, Uses and Abuses of Self-Love
Mirror Mirror, Uses and Abuses of Self-Love
Simon Blackburn
Sour grapes
Sour grapes
Peter Denman
The end of equality
Mickey Kaus
1984
None
George Orwell
Published in 1949, '1984' is a cautionary tale by George Orwell that explores the dangers of totalitarianism. The novel is set in a dystopian future where the world is divided into three super-states, with the protagonist Winston Smith living in Oceania, ruled by the mysterious and omnipotent leader Big Brother. Winston works at the Ministry of Truth, where he rewrites historical records to conform to the Party's ever-changing narrative. He begins an illicit love affair with Julia and starts to rebel against the Party, but they are eventually caught and subjected to brutal torture and indoctrination. The novel highlights themes of government surveillance, manipulation of language and history, and the suppression of individual freedom and independent thought.
Our culture prizes logic and rationality, if not above all else, as two of the most fundamental social traits. But are we missing out by overlooking the irrational? Can logic explain everything, or what is it missing? And is it possible to live (and enjoy) a life led by logic?
Logic, in philosophy and beyond, seems to always to be self-evidently right. Join our three eminent panellists as they variously challenge this assumption and expose the holes in logic's seemingly perfect facade. Iain McGilchrist is a philosopher, neuroscientist, and psychiatrist known for his book The Master and His Emissary. Beatrix Campbell is a writer and activist, especially in the field of women's liberation. Simon Blackburn is a philosopher working especially on metaethics and the philosophy of language. Shahidha Bari, a critic and broadcaster, hosts.
Do you agree with the speakers - is irrationality a key element of life? Email us at podcast@iai.tv with your thoughts or questions on the episode!
Philosophy For Our Times 
