78: Reactionary Fantasies: On “Cancel Culture” and Moral Panic feat. Adrian Daub
Nov 16, 2024
auto_awesome
Adrian Daub, an academic and the co-host of In Bed With the Right, joins the discussion to delve into his book, The Cancel Culture Panic. He explores the historical roots and global ramifications of cancel culture, drawing parallels with historical complaints about political correctness. The conversation highlights the societal fascination with college campuses in the cancel culture narrative and critiques the moral panic surrounding free speech. Daub also unpacks how personal anecdotes shape these discussions, revealing deeper cultural anxieties in our digital age.
The podcast examines the playful nature of a university prank that raises questions about the complexities of language, exclusion, and cultural debates.
It highlights how narratives of cancellation often reflect broader societal anxieties about authority and identity, amplifying real concerns into moral panic.
The discussions reveal a bias in cancellation narratives, prioritizing the experiences of privileged individuals over the genuine struggles of marginalized communities.
Deep dives
The Prank That Became a Metaphor
A university prank involved manipulating the printing system to exclude words associated with postmodernism, highlighting a playful form of cancellation rather than outright censorship. This act calls into question the differences between playful exclusion and serious cultural debates about language and power. It suggests that the ecosystem of ideas is complex and involves negotiations about what can be said in academic circles. The memory of this prank has kept the conversation around language, identity, and exclusion alive within the context of contemporary discussions about cancel culture.
Moral Panic and Cancellation
The term 'cancellation' is examined through the lens of moral panic, where real concerns are amplified and distorted by societal narratives. Historical instances, such as the disruptions caused by the Mod Rocker panic, show how these fears can spiral into widespread societal reactions. In today's discourse, cancellation is often built from minor infractions or misunderstandings that escalate into perceived threats to free speech. This moral panic underscores societal anxieties about authority, identity, and belonging while simultaneously masking the true complexities behind these issues.
Identifying the Main Characters
Cancellation narratives often focus on specific individuals who are framed as victims of a broader cultural assault, creating a relatable storyline. Those at the forefront of these discussions frequently belong to established institutions, echoing already entrenched power dynamics. The discussions ignore the voices of marginalized groups who experience genuine discrimination and silencing on a daily basis. This dramatic focus creates a false dichotomy that obscures the reality of broader social inequities faced by various marginalized communities.
Understanding the Impact of Digital Discourse
Social media plays a crucial role in shaping current perceptions of cancel culture, where the rapid sharing of opinions leads to a distorted view of societal norms. The dynamics of online discourse reveal how emotions and reactions amplify fear around offense and potential backlash. Simultaneously, the concept of self-censorship emerges as people navigate the complexities of expressing opinions, often fearing repercussions. This climate creates a nuanced environment where engagement with controversial topics is fraught with anxiety about public reception and individual consequences.
Unpacking 'Cancel Culture' Narratives
The term 'cancel culture' is critiqued for often excluding discussions on systemic issues and the material consequences that individuals face. While some people express fears about losing their jobs due to societal backlash, those most affected by cancellation typically belong to marginalized backgrounds, bringing attention to an inherent bias in the narrative. These stories may prioritize the voices of privileged individuals over those experiencing real consequences of injustice and discrimination. Additionally, the discussion often simplifies complex situations into binaries, detracting from the nuanced realities of engagement and conflict.
Dialogue and Social Responsibility
The conversation around cancel culture highlights the tension between the desire for open dialogue and the realities of personal responsibility. Advocates for free speech may use cancellation narratives to dismiss calls for accountability, while ignoring the repercussions faced by those on the receiving end of harmful speech. This dynamic emphasizes the need for a societal framework that balances the importance of protecting individuals from harm with allowing diverse opinions to be part of the discourse. Ultimately, fostering a culture of empathy and understanding becomes essential in navigating these complex issues, allowing for thorough conversations about shared humanity.
Abby and Patrick welcome academic, writer, and In Bed With the Right podcast co-host Adrian Daub to discuss his new book, The Cancel Culture Panic: How An American Obsession Went Global. Daub’s book is an exploration of the discourse over “cancel culture” that sets the concept in both historical and global context. In what ways is talk of “cancel culture” merely a return of decades-old complaints about so-called “political correctness,” and in what ways is it different? Why do broad narratives about getting canceled catch on, and what does it mean that anecdotes are so central to their virality? Why do fantasies about college campuses feature so prominently in cancel culture stories? From its origins as a quintessentially American phenomenon, how has the furor over cancel culture crossed borders and languages, crystalized into terms like the French “le wokeism”? What do our fantasies of cancelation activate, what do they confirm, and what are the deeper anxieties they variously betray or conceal? It’s a wide-ranging interrogation of reactionary politics, reaction formations, and histrionics in our chaotic digital moment.
Have you noticed that Freud is back? Got questions about psychoanalysis? Or maybe you’ve traversed the fantasy and lived to tell the tale? Leave us a voicemail! (646) 450-0847
A podcast about psychoanalysis, politics, pop culture, and the ways we suffer now. New episodes on Saturdays. Follow us on social media:
