Swethaa S. Ballakrishnen, "Accidental Feminism: Gender Parity and Selective Mobility Among India’s Professional Elite" (Princeton UP, 2021)
Jan 3, 2025
auto_awesome
Swethaa Ballakrishnen, an Assistant professor of law at UC Irvine, explores the paradox of gender parity in elite Indian law firms. Despite women constituting less than 10% of lawyers in India, they thrive in prestigious firms due to unique structural factors. Ballakrishnen reveals how social dynamics and historical contexts create these unexpected egalitarian outcomes. She also discusses the complexities of navigating gender biases and challenges women face in law and consulting, highlighting the need for nuanced interpretations in feminist discourse.
Swethaa Ballakrishnen's research reveals that women's success in elite Indian law firms is an unintended outcome of socio-economic shifts rather than intentional policies.
The concept of 'Accidental Feminism' illustrates how unique historical and institutional factors create gender parity, challenging traditional narratives of deliberate social change.
Familial support and informal care networks play a crucial role in enabling women lawyers to excel in demanding corporate environments and redefining gender roles.
Deep dives
Professor Swetha Balakrishnan's Academic Journey
Professor Swetha Balakrishnan shares her diverse academic background, starting with her undergraduate education at NALSAR, where she realized her passion for academia and sociolegal studies. After working as a corporate lawyer for a couple of years, she pursued an LLM at Harvard, which laid the foundation for her transition into the sociological aspects of law. Her PhD journey at Stanford enriched her methodological training and shaped her critical feminist perspective on law and globalization. Currently, she serves as an assistant professor at the University of California, Irvine, where she encourages interdisciplinary collaboration across various departments.
Exploring Gender Dynamics in the Legal Profession
Balakrishnan's research reveals a fascinating interplay of gender dynamics within the legal profession in India, particularly after the liberalization reforms of 1991. Her empirical findings show that women were entering and advancing in elite corporate law firms at similar rates as their male counterparts, a stark contrast to the experiences of women in management consultancy. This accidental parity is attributed to a combination of social factors, including urbanity and caste, which created a unique context that allowed women to thrive unencumbered by traditional gender barriers. Balakrishnan argues that the specific historical and institutional circumstances contributed significantly to women's successes in this field.
Accidental Feminism: Unpacking Parity and Meritocracy
The concept of 'Accidental Feminism' is central to Balakrishnan's work, highlighting how women’s successes in corporate law were not the result of deliberate policies but rather an unintended consequence of socio-economic changes. While meritocracy was positioned as the backbone of success, Balakrishnan emphasizes the importance of recognizing how certain social constructions of merit allowed women to navigate their careers effectively. The absence of explicit barriers compared to traditional legal roles meant that women could achieve advancement without the weight of gendered expectations hindering their progress. This dynamic challenges conventional narratives around gender equality, pushing back against the idea that intention drives social change.
The Role of Support Systems and Family Dynamics
Balakrishnan's study further explores the significance of familial support and informal care networks as crucial components in shaping the careers of successful women lawyers. The reliance on lower-caste domestic labor and supportive family structures facilitated a work-life balance that allowed these women to excel in demanding corporate environments. Interestingly, the cultural acceptance of such support systems often resulted in shifts in family dynamics, transforming traditional gender roles. The evolution of these roles illustrates how personal and professional domains intersect to create pathways for empowerment and change, even if the changes occur inadvertently.
Navigating Identity and Change in Legal Practices
The book probes deeper into how successful women lawyers negotiate their identities within the corporate setting and the wider implications for gender constructs in professional contexts. Balakrishnan notes that while women often benefit from being perceived as competent and capable, harmful essentialist stereotypes linger, complicating their success narratives. The struggles these women face reflect broader societal dilemmas regarding gender and professionalism, especially in a rapidly modernizing context. Ultimately, Balakrishnan suggests that the ongoing discourse around gender in the legal profession opens new avenues for understanding both individual agency and systemic inequities.
In India, elite law firms offer a surprising oasis for women within a hostile, predominantly male industry. Less than 10 percent of the country's lawyers are female, but women in the most prestigious firms are significantly represented both at entry and partnership. Elite workspaces are notorious for being unfriendly to new actors, so what allows for aberration in certain workspaces?
Drawing from observations and interviews with more than 130 elite professionals, Accidental Feminism: Gender Parity and Selective Mobility Among India’s Professional Elite(Princeton UP, 2021) examines how a range of underlying mechanisms-gendered socialization and essentialism, family structures and dynamics, and firm and regulatory histories-afford certain professionals egalitarian outcomes that are not available to their local and global peers. Juxtaposing findings on the legal profession with those on elite consulting firms, Swethaa Ballakrishnen reveals that parity arises not from a commitment to create feminist organizations, but from structural factors that incidentally come together to do gender differently. Simultaneously, their research offers notes of caution: while conditional convergence may create equality in ways that more targeted endeavors fail to achieve, "accidental" developments are hard to replicate, and are, in this case, buttressed by embedded inequalities. Ballakrishnen examines whether gender parity produced without institutional sanction should still be considered feminist.
In offering new ways to think about equality movements and outcomes, Accidental Feminism forces readers to critically consider the work of intention in progress narratives.
Noopur Raval is a postdoctoral researcher working at the intersection of Information Studies, STS, Media Studies and Anthropology.