Geneticist Adam Rutherford discusses the harmful impact of Linnaean taxonomy, from scientific racism to SEO. The conversation covers human evolution theories, genetics, AI biases, and language evolution. Can we break free from taxonomy's influence?
Linnaeus's taxonomy laid the foundation for scientific racism, perpetuating harmful stereotypes and hierarchies.
Rigid categorization in AI can perpetuate presentist biases, limitations in language understanding, and reinforce societal stereotypes.
Deep dives
The Harmful Legacy of Taxonomy by Carl Linnaeus
Carl Linnaeus, a Swedish botanist in the 17th and 18th century, created a system of taxonomy that classifies all living things based on genus and species. While this system provided a universal language for biologists, it rooted in a pre-Darwin era, reflecting a creationist perspective rather than an evolutionary one. The classification system, though initially useful, becomes limiting and flawed when applied rigidly, failing to account for the transitional nature of biology.
Taxonomy's Influence on Scientific Racism
Linnaeus's classification of humans into subspecies laid the groundwork for scientific racism, perpetuating harmful stereotypes and hierarchies. The categorization based on skin color and physical attributes led to the birth of an era of scientific racism, promoting false notions of racial superiority and inferiority.
Implications of Taxonomy in Modern AI and Language Models
As AI and large language models rely on taxonomies to order information, there is a risk of perpetuating presentist biases and limitations in language understanding. The potential lack of nuance and flexibility in categorization within AI systems may lead to inaccuracies and reinforce existing societal stereotypes.
Counterfactual Exploration: Imagining a World without Linnaeus's Taxonomy
Exploring a counterfactual scenario where genetics were discovered before Linnaeus raises questions about the historical impact of taxonomy on scientific racism. Reflecting on the ephemeral nature of racial classification and the mutable aspects of language and communication highlights the limitations and dangers of rigid categorization based on superficial traits.
For the latest episode in our series about the hold of bad ideas, we welcome back the geneticist Adam Rutherford to talk about Linnaean taxonomy, a seemingly innocuous scheme of classification that has had deeply pernicious consequences. From scientific racism to social stratification to search engine optimisation, taxonomy gets everywhere. Can we escape its grip?
Sign up now to PPF+ to get ad-free listening and bonus episodes to accompany every series. Coming soon: two bonus bad ideas just for PPF+ subscribers www.ppfideas.com
Next time on The History of Bad Ideas: Helen Lewis on women against the enfranchisement of women.