The Commentary Magazine Podcast Trump Warns Hamas
37 snips
Oct 15, 2025 Eliana Johnson, Editor of the Washington Free Beacon, joins the discussion on Trump’s statements urging Hamas to disarm or face consequences. They critically assess claims that Trump followed Biden's lead on the Gaza ceasefire and examine media narratives around the diplomatic success. Eliana also highlights the troubling treatment of Palestinian civilians by Hamas, criticizing the lack of coverage. Additionally, they dissect the New York Times’ praise for Zohran Mamdani, questioning his electability given his radical positions on Israel.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Trump's 'We Will Disarm Them' Moment
- Donald Trump's public vow to 'disarm' Hamas expanded U.S. security guarantees beyond the formal 20-point plan.
- His rhetoric signaled a shift from diplomatic hedging to blunt deterrence that surprised the hosts.
Cease-Fire Drains Attention And Reveals Hamas
- The cease-fire's immediate effect reduced global attention on Gaza and altered incentives for media and activists.
- Hamas's rapid internecine violence exposed its nature and undermined 'ceasefire now' advocates, per the hosts.
Brooklyn Bridge Protest At Son's Bar Mitzvah
- John recounts how 'ceasefire now' protesters once blocked the Brooklyn Bridge on his son's bar mitzvah night.
- He describes that disruption as a personal grievance tied into his critique of the movement.