James Wright, an author and architectural archaeologist known for debunking medieval myths, dives into the quirks of medieval sanitation. He discusses why monks feared the latrine and reveals fascinating sanitation practices of the time. Listeners learn about the communal nature of toilets and surprising historical vulnerabilities, including notable figures' tragic fates in the loo. Wright also highlights early advancements in toilet technology, challenging modern perceptions and blending humor with deeper societal fears surrounding hygiene.
Medieval individuals placed importance on hygiene, employing various materials like moss for cleanliness despite limited understanding of microbiology.
Cultural attitudes towards toilets intertwined humor and fear, reflecting societal ambivalence regarding bodily functions and their moral implications.
Deep dives
Medieval Toilet Perceptions
The common perception of medieval toilets often depicts them as unsanitary and filthy environments, but historical evidence suggests a more nuanced reality. Contrary to popular belief, people living in the medieval period were likely just as concerned about cleanliness as modern individuals, understanding that filth could lead to health problems. They had specific locations for toilet use, ranging from communal latrines to private guard robes in nobility's homes, and although these facilities varied widely based on social status, many individuals utilized necessary houses located away from living spaces. This understanding of sanitation shows that while they may not have grasped the concept of microbiology, they still recognized the importance of hygiene and sought to mitigate unpleasant odors and disease.
Communal Toilet Experiences
Medieval toilets often included elements of sociability, as many experiences were shared in communal setups like guard robes. For example, some royal and noble households featured multi-stall toilets where individuals would sit side by side, which contrasts sharply with the modern expectation of privacy in restroom facilities. Historical etiquette also reflects this communal nature; guidance from scholars indicated that politeness prohibited conversation during use, hinting that engaging while on the toilet was not uncommon. Such insights into communal toilet experiences highlight how social norms around bodily functions have evolved over time.
Hygiene Practices and Cleaning Methods
To achieve cleanliness after using the toilet in the medieval period, individuals likely employed various materials for wiping, with moss being a prevalent choice due to its absorbent qualities. Archaeological findings support this, as excavations have revealed remnants of moss and straw in latrines, indicating that even lower-status individuals made attempts at hygiene. While there is less direct evidence of handwashing practices post-use, it is plausible that some facilities were equipped with bowls for cleaning hands, reflecting an awareness of hygiene. These practices reveal that maintaining cleanliness was valued, even if the specific methods were far less sophisticated than today’s standards.
Cultural Attitudes Toward Toilets
Medieval culture held complex attitudes toward toilets, ranging from humor to fear about bodily waste. Many literary works from the era, including works by Chaucer, demonstrate a tradition of scatological humor, showcasing people's everyday relationship with toilets. Conversely, there was a theological perspective that associated defecation with sin, prompting fears of the devil lurking in latrines, as clerics viewed waste as evidence of human corruption. This duality of humor and fear reflects a broader cultural ambivalence toward bodily functions and highlights how these societal attitudes have impacted our understanding of sanitation and morality throughout history.
Why were medieval monks so afraid of going to the loo? In the second episode of our mini-series Toilets Through Time, David Musgrove heads into the dark and dangerous world of medieval latrines on a quest to find out. Helping him navigate the risks of fire, filth and eternal damnation that came with paying a visit in the Middle Ages is author, architectural archaeologist and medieval myth-buster James Wright.
The HistoryExtra podcast is produced by the team behind BBC History Magazine.