Commotion with Elamin Abdelmahmoud What does the show Surrounded tell us about rage bait culture
Aug 27, 2025
Riley Yesno, an Anishinaabe writer and researcher, joins Elle Jones, a poet and political professor, to dissect the YouTube series 'Surrounded.' They evaluate its unique debate format that may prioritize divisiveness over genuine dialogue. Discussing a controversial immigration debate, they examine media's role in shaping discourse. The conversation touches on how alternative formats influence public engagement and the rise of rage bait culture, while also reflecting on the importance of empathy and personal storytelling in bridging ideological divides.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Format Encourages Spectacle
- Surrounded's format sets one prepared guest against a rushed crowd, creating performative chaos rather than careful debate.
- The rush-to-seat and kick-out rules incentivize spectacle over thoughtful exchange.
Jordan Peterson Episode Example
- The Jordan Peterson episode demonstrates moments of calm, intellectual exchange amid the show's chaos.
- That episode ran an hour and a half and included both measured and heated interactions.
Social Media Ecosystem Drives Casting
- Guests are often social media influencers, and the show fuels a cycle of clips, responses, and monetized attention.
- This ecosystem amplifies performative moments to benefit creators and platforms more than public understanding.