Steve Matthews, a countercult apologist, and Coltin Rohn, a former ICC member turned RCW leader, dive deep into the recent split within the International Christian Church. They discuss the emotional toll on departing members and explore varying perspectives on unity and leadership. Coltin shares firsthand experiences and motivations behind the exodus, while Steve critiques the ICC's historical controversies and challenges in authority. Together, they propose a return to scriptural teachings, urging followers to navigate these turbulent waters with clarity and faith.
The podcast explores the emotional and spiritual turmoil faced by ICC members amidst the significant split with the RCW movement.
It critiques the controlling nature of discipleship within the ICC, advocating for personal conviction over rigid leadership compliance.
The hosts challenge the numbers-driven mentality of the ICC, arguing that true growth should reflect individual transformation rather than mere statistics.
Deep dives
Crowdfunding and Ministry Support
The podcast emphasizes the critical need for continued crowdfunding to support the ministry's operations. The hosts share that they currently operate on only 10 to 15 percent of the monthly funding required and express concern over the infrequency of new episodes. They encourage listeners who have benefitted from the past content to consider making generous contributions. This approach allows them to maintain a free resource for cult survivors and others seeking guidance without imposing a paywall.
Examining the International Christian Church (ICC)
A deep dive into the International Christian Church (ICC) reveals significant current tensions and a major split within its community. The hosts introduce the ICC as one of the most aggressive movements on college campuses, focusing on its unique doctrine and methods of recruitment. They underscore that many individuals face emotional trauma due to divided alliances and relationships arising from this split. The discussion aims to provide insights and biblical perspectives to help individuals navigate this complex situation.
The Role of Discipleship and Authority
The podcast outlines the controversial role of discipleship within the ICC, highlighting how it can often lead to unhealthy dynamics where individuals are pressured to comply with authority figures. The hosts share personal anecdotes, illustrating scenarios where decisions are made based on what leaders permit rather than personal convictions driven by the Holy Spirit. This concept has parallels with mind control dynamics typically found in cult-like environments, where questioning authority can result in severe emotional backlash. They stress that true discipleship should be empowering, not controlling, encouraging personal relationships with Christ over rigid obedience to human leaders.
Probability of Growth and Numbers Worship
A significant focus is placed on how membership numbers have been tied to perceptions of God's grace within the ICC. The hosts critique this numbers-driven mentality, suggesting it detracts from the genuine message of the gospel and places undue pressure on members to produce visible results. They discuss biblical examples, including the parable of the sower, to argue that true growth must not merely be quantified in numbers, as even Jesus had periods of loss of followers. This leads to the assertion that validation of a movement should not rely on numerical growth, but rather on the authentic transformation of individual lives.
The Illusion of Choice and Authority Structures
The podcast discusses how the current divisions within the ICC and the emergence of the Restored Church Worldwide (RCW) create an illusion of choice between two movements, both of which maintain controlling structures. The hosts elaborate on the sense of urgency members feel to align with one faction or risk being labeled as rebellious or fallen away. They emphasize that true freedom in Christ does not necessitate loyalty to a specific organization or leader but instead focuses on individual relationships with God. The conversation challenges listeners to rethink their involvement and consider a faith rooted in autonomy and personal conviction rather than the dictates of human leadership.
This week, we kick off a three-week deep dive into the International Christian Church (ICC) with a look at the current split within the movement. Many ICC members are choosing to leave and join the Restored Church Worldwide (RCW), forcing a tough decision: remain in the ICC to preserve its unity, which they’ve believed to be “the very Movement of God,” or follow other disciples into a new movement that’s excited to restore the Book of Acts in this generation. In this episode, countercult apologist Steve Matthews and former longtime ICC member Coltin Rohn examine the growing divide between the ICC and RCW, offering a third alternative grounded in Scripture for struggling ICC disciples. Don't miss this powerful episode, and be sure to tune in next week as we continue our deep dive into the roots of the ICC, the International Churches of Christ, and the Campbell-Stone Restoration Movement that laid the foundation for the creation of the Boston Church of Christ in 1979.
Please consider partnering with Cultish to continue this ministry: HERE
The ExposingTheCults website is coming soon! For more content from ExposingTheCults please check out and subscribe at
