Bonus: Is America on the Path to Authoritarianism?
Feb 21, 2025
auto_awesome
Eve Fairbanks, a senior editor at Foreign Affairs, engages with scholars Steven Levitsky and Lucan Way on the alarming signs of democratic erosion in the U.S. They discuss 'competitive authoritarianism,' where elections persist, but the state targets opposition. The conversation highlights the GOP's evolving power dynamics under Trump, including bureaucratic weaponization and media cooptation. Despite the risks of political polarization, they explore hope and strategies for resisting authoritarianism from within the party, emphasizing the need for a robust democratic culture.
The podcast discusses the emergence of competitive authoritarianism in the U.S., highlighting how elections persist while state power is used to undermine opposition.
The transformation of the Republican Party under Trump emphasizes the consolidation of power, posing significant risks to traditional democratic norms and governance.
Deep dives
Emerging Competitive Authoritarianism
The emergence of a new form of competitive authoritarianism within the United States is discussed, highlighting how these regimes maintain elections while systematically undermining the opposition. This approach allows the ruling party to weaponize the state against its critics, using legal and bureaucratic mechanisms to tilt the political playing field. The concept underscores that while there may be competitive elections, the environment is rigged against any serious challenge to the authority. Examples from global scenarios illustrate how this trend has manifested in countries like Poland, where elections occur but are dominated by political manipulation.
Shifts in Republican Party Dynamics
The discussion examines the significant shift in the Republican Party's dynamics since Trump's first term, demonstrating how he has solidified control over the party. Unlike his previous term, where he lacked a cohesive strategy and allies, Trump now operates with unwavering support from loyalists, drastically altering the political landscape. This dominant hold allows him greater latitude to manipulate federal institutions and enact policies without checks from within his party. The implications of this transformation raise concerns about the erosion of traditional democratic norms and governance.
Weaponization of Bureaucracy
The podcast explores the critical role of bureaucratic control in establishing an authoritarian regime, emphasizing how leaders often target civil services for purging to secure their power. By dismantling independent bureaucratic agencies, authoritarians can manipulate governmental powers for political advantage, undermining democratic processes. Examples are drawn from other nations where populist leaders have similarly attacked bureaucratic independence, illustrating the dangers for the United States. The discussion reinforces that robust bureaucracies serve as essential safeguards against authoritarian tendencies.
Opposition to Authoritarianism
The potential for opposition to authoritarianism within the United States is highlighted, focusing on the importance of maintaining a robust civil society and political engagement. Despite growing despondence among opposition figures and the general public, there are indications that resistance could rise in response to Trump's actions. The need for a united opposition that recognizes the threats posed by competitive authoritarianism is emphasized, encouraging citizens to overcome apathy and fear. This sentiment reveals that while challenges are considerable, the resilience and engagement of the populace remain critical in safeguarding democratic values.
A month into U.S. President Donald Trump’s second term in office, many are alarmed by what they see as emerging signs of democratic erosion. In a new essay, called “The Path to American Authoritarianism,” the scholars Steven Levitsky and Lucan Way make the case that such alarm is justified—that the administration’s early moves could herald an irreversible transformation of the U.S. political system, with major implications for global democracy.
Drawing from their research on democratic decline worldwide, Levitsky and Way argue that the United States faces a particular kind of risk that many observers miss—a form of so-called competitive authoritarianism, in which elections continue but the state apparatus is weaponized against opposition.
Levitsky is David Rockefeller Professor of Latin American Studies and Professor of Government at Harvard University and a Senior Fellow for Democracy at the Council on Foreign Relations. Way is Distinguished Professor of Democracy at the University of Toronto Distinguished Professor of Democracy in the Department of Political Science at the University of Toronto and a Fellow of the Royal Society of Canada. They are the authors of Competitive Authoritarianism: Hybrid Regimes After the Cold War.
In a special bonus episode, they speak with senior editor Eve Fairbanks about the global playbook for authoritarian regimes—and the stakes for American democracy.