Kevin Vallier, an expert on conflicts in politics and the aggravating effects of ideology, discusses the role of trust and liberal institutions in politics. The conversation explores the measurement and restoration of social trust, the importance of trust in resolving conflicts and avoiding dehumanization, and the significance of trust in social interactions and political institutions. Vallier also delves into the concept of toleration in liberalism and advocates for the restoration of trust through more liberal arrangements.
Political polarization is viewed as one of the biggest threats to a free society, with falling trust as a cause and consequence.
Respecting each other's rights and embracing politically liberal ideals can help build trust across ideological perspectives.
The declining levels of trust contribute to polarization, and restoring trust requires creating inclusive institutions and policies.
Deep dives
Political Polarization as a Threat to Society
The podcast episode highlights how political polarization is viewed as one of the biggest threats to a free society. The speaker, reflecting on his previous skepticism, acknowledges that recent years have convinced him of the heightened and concerning nature of political divisions. The discussion centers around the concept of a 'cold civil war' in the United States, referring to the deep ideological divisions that exist between different groups. Falling trust is identified as both a cause and a consequence of this polarization, with potential negative consequences. According to the speaker, liberal institutions are crucial for sustaining trust between diverse perspectives, as they allow individuals and groups the freedom to live according to their own beliefs. It is argued that even non-liberals should be on board with a classical liberal order, which emphasizes freedom of association and minimizes domination by opposing ideologies. The aim is to build a society where diverse perspectives can coexist and trust can be restored by seeing liberal institutions as preferable to alternative systems.
The Possibility of Politics Without War
The podcast episode explores the idea that politics does not inherently need to be warlike, but that it often becomes so due to failures in liberal practices. The speaker argues that by respecting each other's rights and embracing certain politically liberal ideals, trust can be built across different ideological perspectives. The discussion emphasizes the importance of compromise and the process of finding common ground, rather than focusing solely on the end result. It is suggested that a commitment to liberalism, with its emphasis on individual freedoms and respect for diverse perspectives, can help mitigate the warlike nature of political discourse. The speaker acknowledges that there are challenges in tolerating those who do not believe in coexistence or toleration, but emphasizes the need to draw the line at those who seek to impose their beliefs on others without reciprocal respect.
The Role of Trust in Political Divisions
The podcast episode delves into the role of trust in perpetuating or reducing political divisions. The declining levels of trust, both social and political, are identified as significant factors contributing to the current state of polarization. The speaker suggests a potential causal feedback loop between falling trust and increasing divergence, resulting in a vicious cycle. It is argued that restoring trust is crucial in mitigating the destructive effects of polarization. The discussion highlights the importance of creating institutions and policies that foster trust by respecting people's rights, ensuring procedural fairness, and addressing concerns of various groups. The speaker also alludes to the influence of media in shaping trust perceptions. Overall, the episode emphasizes the need to address falling trust levels and work towards inclusive, trusting, and tolerant societies.
The Importance of Trust in Politics
Politics must prioritize the establishment and maintenance of trust among individuals and groups. Trust is a valuable social resource that promotes cooperation, economic growth, and minimizes violence and corruption. The erosion of trust poses significant challenges to societal cohesion and should be a concern across political perspectives.
Liberal Institutions as Trust-Builders
Classical liberal institutions are uniquely capable of fostering trust and reducing the likelihood of politics being war-like. These institutions allow diverse groups to live out their convictions to varying degrees, creating an environment of tolerance and respect. Such liberal arrangements prioritize individual liberties and private property rights while recognizing the need for modest welfare programs. By advocating for more liberal political arrangements, trust can be restored and politics can be transformed into a more cooperative and less confrontational endeavor.
In this conversation from January 2020, Alex Aragona speaks with Kevin Vallier about conflicts in politics and how ideology aggravates them, and whether liberal institutions can help us trust each other more.
References from Episode 26 with Kevin Vallier:
You can purchase Kevin Vallier’s book Must Politics be Warhere
You can purchase the book Polarization: What Everyone Needs to Know here