Sohrab Ahmari, a sharp commentator on political issues, and Geoff Shullenberger, a keen cultural critic, join the discussion with Matthew Schmitz. They dissect Kamala Harris's controversial ties with Silicon Valley donors and the electoral risks involved. The conversation dives into the Venezuelan crisis, highlighting its implications for Latino leadership. The trio also tackles the evolution of identity politics and allyship, questioning the genuine support behind public endorsements and examining the complexities of race in contemporary political discourse.
Kamala Harris's political strategy risks alienating key Rust Belt voters by yielded to elite donor pressures against popular tariff policies.
The Republican narrative against Harris focuses on her perceived political inconsistency and elite interests, reflecting past strategies against Obama.
Deep dives
Kamala's Political Strategy and Risks
Kamala Harris's political strategy involves gaining support from influential donors, notably Reed Hoffman, who seeks the removal of certain economic policies. This includes significant pressure to eliminate tariffs, which are popular in battleground states that have pivoted towards the Republican Party due to Trump's protectionist approach. The argument is that conceding to Hoffman's demands could alienate key voter demographics in these crucial Rust Belt areas that value tariff protections for their local industries. Additionally, there is concern that distancing from antitrust regulations under Lina Khan could weaken Biden's economic message, as these rules are seen as essential to combatting corporate consolidations that burden American consumers.
GOP Messaging Against Kamala Harris
The Republican approach to attacking Kamala Harris centers on her previous left-leaning statements during her primary campaign, where she tried to appeal to both progressive and moderate voters. This duality is considered a liability as it creates a narrative of inconsistency and pandering, something reminiscent of strategies used against Obama in the past. However, it is noted that this tactic of painting her as a radical without effective counterarguments might backfire, just like similar strategies did against Obama and Trump. Thus, the Republicans might need to refine their messaging to focus on her perceived alignment with elite interests rather than just labeling her with leftist ideologies.
Identity Politics in Democratic Organizing
Recent Democratic organizing efforts, particularly calls for support of Kamala Harris, reflect a complex interplay of identity politics, especially through gatherings like 'White Dudes for Kamala.' These events highlight the evolving nature of political allyship, where earnestness may be replaced by a more ironic acknowledgment of identity categories. Nevertheless, such gatherings continue to grapple with the notion of race in American politics, prompting questions about whether this branding is genuinely impactful or merely self-congratulatory. Despite the cringe-worthy undertones, there is speculation that the fervor associated with identity politics has diminished, allowing for a more laid-back approach to political engagement.
Unrest surges in Venezuela, white guys convene in support of Kamala Harris, and Matt Stoller asks if Harris will be Hillary Clinton 2.0. Sohrab Ahmari and Geoff Shullenberger join Matthew Schmitz.
Compact Magazine is reader-supported. Become a member and gain unlimited access. https://compactmag.com/subscribe
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
