Shadow Minister for Creative Industries and Digital, Secretary of State for Wales, Executive Europe Editor, classical singer, and Plaid Cymru Westminster leader discuss controversies surrounding the home secretary's accusations, biases in policing protests, controversy surrounding a government official, breaking the ministerial code, British figure's writing and oil extraction in the North Sea, government response to climate change and energy security, and the implementation of a 20 mph speed limit in Wales.
The debate surrounding Suella Braverman brings attention to the complexities of balancing freedom of speech and upholding public safety.
Continuing with oil and gas extraction in the North Sea is incompatible with achieving net zero emissions and creating financial benefits for the UK.
Implementing a nationwide 20 miles per hour speed limit raises concerns about its impact on rural areas and calls for more consultation and tailored decisions based on specific needs.
Deep dives
Should Suella Braverman go?
There is a debate over whether Suella Braverman, the home secretary, should be dismissed. Braverman has accused the police of political bias, particularly in their handling of pro-Palestinian and right-wing nationalist protests. Some argue that her remarks undermine the police and that she should do more to support their work, while others feel she is raising valid concerns about the safety of Jewish people. The issue has sparked a broader discussion about hate crimes, freedom of speech, and the role of the home secretary in relation to the police.
Should Suella Braverman go?
Critics argue that Suella Braverman has been divisive in her role as home secretary and has displayed a degree of hatred towards various groups. They also question her judgment and claim that she has undermined the police's ability to do their job properly. Others, however, believe that her concerns about the safety of Jewish people are valid and that the focus should be on addressing those issues rather than debating whether she should be dismissed. The debate highlights the challenges faced by politicians in handling sensitive issues and the need for a balanced approach in maintaining public safety and upholding individual rights.
Should Suella Braverman go?
Opinions are divided on whether Suella Braverman should be sacked as home secretary. Some perceive her statements as inflammatory and claim that she has shown a lack of respect for the prime minister and the police. They argue that her actions have undermined the police's authority and their ability to maintain peace during protests. On the other hand, some argue that Braverman's concerns about the safety of Jewish people should not be dismissed. They believe that the focus should be on addressing the valid issues raised rather than on her choice of words. The discussion highlights the complexities of balancing freedom of speech with maintaining public confidence in law enforcement.
The compatibility of oil and gas extraction with reaching net zero
The podcast discusses the issue of annual licenses for oil and gas exploration in the North Sea and its compatibility with reaching net zero emissions. The panel highlights that continuing with oil and gas extraction is not compatible with achieving net zero targets. They argue that the extracted oil will not be refined in the UK and will not bring financial benefits to the country. There is a suggestion to create a British energy company to focus on developing green energy and creating jobs.
The implementation of a nationwide 20 miles per hour speed limit
The podcast addresses the question of whether the rest of the UK should follow Wales in implementing a nationwide 20 miles per hour speed limit. The panel discusses the benefits of lower speed limits in residential areas and near schools and hospitals. However, concerns are raised about the blanket implementation and the impact on rural areas. There is a call for more consultation and review of the policy to ensure common sense decisions are made according to the specific needs of different areas.
Fiona Bruce presents an hour of topical debate from Llandudno. On the panel tonight, Chris Bryant MP, Shadow Minister for Creative Industries and Digital, David TC Davies MP, Secretary of State for Wales, Anne McElvoy, Executive Europe Editor and Head of Podcasting at Politico, Camilla Kerslake, classical and opera singer, and co-founder of The Kerslake Robshaw Foundation, and Liz Saville-Roberts MP, Plaid Cymru Westminster leader.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
