In this podcast, the case of Alma Tirtschke is dissected, questioning the innocence of Colin Ross in her murder. The podcast explores witness testimonies, family alibis, questionable evidence, and emotional appeals. It delves into the aftermath of Alma's pardon and the pursuit of justice to clear Colin Ross's name.
Witness testimony credibility was questioned due to criminal backgrounds and inconsistencies, raising doubts about Colin Ross's guilt.
Prosecution's evidence like Alma's hairs and torn fabric was challenged for reliability, casting doubt on Colin's conviction.
Inadequate pursuit of new witnesses and lack of thorough investigations led to denial of Colin Ross's appeals, highlighting flaws in the judicial process.
Deep dives
The Unreliable Witness Accounts
Witness accounts presented at the trial, including those of Francis Upton and other disreputable individuals, were heavily critiqued. The witnesses had criminal histories and conflicting stories, with some admitting to providing testimony after the reward was announced. The defense argued that these witnesses lacked credibility and could have colluded to falsely accuse Colin Ross.
Inconsistent and Flawed Evidence
The prosecution's case relied heavily on evidence such as Alma's hairs found at the saloon and the torn fabric allegedly linked to the crime. However, inconsistencies arose in witness testimonies, and the evidence's reliability was challenged. The analysis of the hairs lacked expert knowledge, and the fabric piece found wasn't definitively connected to the victim. The defense highlighted discrepancies in the evidence that cast doubt on Colin's guilt.
Denied Appeals and Lack of Investigation
Despite new witnesses coming forward post-conviction, Colin Ross's appeals were denied without thorough investigations. Witness statements from Joseph Graham and George Crilly, detailing their encounters on the day of the crime, were not adequately pursued by authorities. The appeals process lacked preparation time, and key witnesses' accounts were not fully presented, contributing to the rejection of the appeals and upholding of the guilty verdict.
A Deep Dive into the Tersky Case Reveals Innocence
Despite the prevailing belief in Colin's guilt and the push for capital punishment, efforts were made to seek mercy and prove his innocence. Edie Ross tirelessly fought for her son, with some acknowledgment of weaknesses in the prosecution's case. Despite the uphill battle, Colin remained accepting of his fate and expressed gratitude towards his family, culminating in an emotional farewell before his extended execution. Years later, new evidence emerged, showcasing discrepancies in the case and leading to Colin's posthumous exoneration.
Uncovering an Alternative Suspect in Alma Tursky's Murder
George Murphy, a potential suspect in Alma Tursky's murder, had a history of suspicious actions towards Viola, Alma's sister, leading to Kevin Morgan's chilling revelation. Viola's nightmares and memories pointed towards Murphy's predatory behavior, sparking a theory that he could have been Alma's killer. Discussing the circumstances surrounding Alma's disappearance and murder, including a mysterious letter indicating an alternate perspective on the true perpetrator, raises questions about the initial investigation and the overlooked information that could have exonerated Colin and shed light on Alma's real killer.
