The path of political disintegration (with Peter Turchin)
Oct 31, 2023
auto_awesome
Peter Turchin, author of 'End Times: Elites, Counter-Elites, and the Path of Political Disintegration', joins the podcast to discuss the causes of political communities falling apart. They explore extreme inequality, wealth redistribution, and the urgency of preventing political disintegration. The speaker also discusses a sense of impending doom and encourages action to prevent the collapse of civilization.
Reversing popular immiseration and reducing inequality are crucial to preventing societal breakdown and instability.
Long-term commitment, collaboration, and investment in social science research are necessary to bring about meaningful reforms and ensure long-term stability in society.
Deep dives
The Predictability of Political Disintegration
Peter Turchin, a social scientist, discusses his book 'End Times' and his approach to studying history and social systems. He explains how the study of past societies has revealed a recurrent pattern of integrative periods followed by periods of crisis. Turchin identifies three key drivers of societal breakdown: popular immiseration, overproduction of wealthy elites, and overproduction of lower-rank elites. He emphasizes the importance of reversing popular immiseration by aligning wage growth with economic growth. Turchin also suggests increasing taxes on the wealthy, funding infrastructure projects, and creating jobs for overproduced degree holders. He highlights the need for a long-term perspective and cooperation between politicians, opinion influencers, and scientists to bring about necessary reforms.
The Urgency of Addressing Inequality
Turchin highlights the dangers of growing inequality and its role in societal instability. He argues that excessive inequality serves as a proxy for the operation of the 'wealth pump,' which redistributes resources from the poor to the rich. By reducing popular immiseration and implementing policies that shut down the wealth pump, such as increasing minimum wages and taxing the wealthy, societies can avoid the destructive consequences of inequality. Turchin agrees that radically reducing inequality is a practical and necessary path to prevent societal collapse. However, he cautions that it may not guarantee a solution in the short-term, as addressing the crisis requires long-term commitment and persuasion of the majority.
Lessons from History and Success Stories
Turchin draws insights from historical success stories, like the New Deal and the Great Reforms in Russia, to outline potential strategies for avoiding catastrophe. He suggests investing in social science research, building models to test different ideas, and understanding potential nonlinear feedback effects. Turchin advocates for giving workers the ability to organize, increasing taxes on the wealthy, reducing the military budget, and focusing on creating jobs while addressing overproduction of degree holders. He emphasizes that the path out of the crisis is not guaranteed, but these strategies can pave the way for long-term stability and prosperity.
The Urgency of Long-Term Thinking
Turchin acknowledges the terrifying nature of the current moment, characterized by political disintegration and the fragility of liberal democracy. While immediate solutions for the short-term may seem limited, he emphasizes the need to work towards a future where people's lives improve with each generation. Turchin advocates for collaboration between politicians, opinion influencers, and scientists to implement reforms that reverse popular immiseration and shut down the wealth pump. He cautions against expecting immediate results and highlights the need for long-term thinking and investment in quantitative social science to address the complex and interdependent factors contributing to societal breakdown.
When Nick warned back in 2013 that the pitchforks were coming, he meant that if we continued immiserating the majority of citizens by enriching a wealthy few at the expense of everyone else, an uprising was inevitable. Unfortunately, this warning is still just as relevant ten years later. Peter Turchin joins the podcast to discuss his new book, End Times: Elites, Counter-Elites, and the Path of Political Disintegration, which looks to history (as well as the current turmoil in the United States) to better understand exactly what causes political communities to fall apart.
Peter Turchin is Project Leader at the Complexity Science Hub in Vienna, Research Associate at University of Oxford, and Emeritus Professor at the University of Connecticut.