Delving into the decline of ESG investing popularity and exploring the challenges faced by fund managers. Discussing the evolution of ESG terminology and impact investing, alongside the complexities of sustainable investing. Exploring the differences between WTI and Brent Crude, and the significance of oil price benchmarks in the global economy. Understanding contango and backwardation in investment strategies, especially in relation to oil exposure and roll costs.
ESG funds are experiencing significant outflows due to underperformance and backlash, leading to closures and rebranding.
The challenges of objectively evaluating companies based on their ESG performance highlight the need for more standardized metrics.
Deep dives
ESG Funds Facing Backlash and Outflows
ESG funds, which promised to save the planet while providing higher returns, are now experiencing significant outflows as investors withdraw their money due to disappointing performances and a growing ESG backlash. Fund managers are not only avoiding launching new ESG funds but are also shutting down existing ones. The trend of closures and rebranding away from the ESG label is evident, with 32 sustainable funds closing last year and six dropping the ESG badge. The sharp decline in investor interest and the underperformance of ESG funds compared to non-ESG options, as highlighted by statistics, indicate a shift away from the once-popular ESG trend.
Challenges and Misconceptions of ESG Investing
ESG investing faces challenges and misconceptions as revealed through a critical analysis of the ESG movement. Advocates had touted ESG investments as a way to balance environmental and social consciousness with financial gains, but the reality has been different. Research shows that ESG ETFs have underperformed compared to their non-ESG counterparts, indicating a gap between the promise of higher returns and the actual outcome. The discrepancy in fee structures and the blending of environmental, social, and governance criteria pose additional challenges to the effectiveness and clarity of ESG investments.
The Subjectivity and Complexity of ESG Scores
The subjectivity and complexity of ESG scores are highlighted, revealing the challenges in objectively evaluating companies based on their ESG performance. ESG indices use self-reported data and a variety of criteria to assign scores, leading to inconsistencies and lack of objectivity. Studies show low correlations between different ESG indices, indicating the subjective nature of ESG scoring. The comparison with credit ratings, which exhibit high correlation, underscores the need for more standardized and objective metrics in evaluating ESG performance.
Impact Investing as an Alternative Approach
Impact investing emerges as an alternative approach to ESG investing, focusing on targeted investments that align with specific social or environmental goals. Impact funds concentrate on initiatives such as reducing CO2 emissions and supporting sustainable development goals. Unlike traditional ESG funds, impact investing emphasizes active control and engagement with companies to drive positive change. While impact investing may involve higher risks and lower returns due to concentration and non-profit maximization, it offers a more direct and tailored approach to supporting ethical and impactful initiatives.
ESG funds lured investors with the promise of simultaneously saving the planet and achieving higher returns. But after years of inflows, investors are pulling their money. Is there a better approach to sustainable investment? And in today’s Dumb Question of the Week: Why are there multiple oil prices?
Thanks to Freetrade for sponsoring this episode.
Get a free share worth between £100 and £2,100 when you open & top up, or transfer an ISA and/or SIPP. Head over to Freetrade.io/transfer. New and existing customers. Min £10k investment. Annual subscription required. Limited time offer.
Capital at risk. ISA and SIPP eligibility, tax rules and T&Cs apply. Free share value varies on the amount topped up or transferred. Ends 5 April 2024.
This podcast is for informational and entertainment purposes and is not financial advice. We do not provide recommendations or endorse any decision to buy, sell or hold any security. We cannot be held responsible for any actions listeners may take and investors are encouraged to seek independent financial advice.
Copyright 2023 Many Happy Returns
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode