In a fascinating discussion, renowned sociologist Hartmut Rosa explores the complexities of modernity, focusing on the role of resonance in living a fulfilling life. He highlights the tension between the desire for control and the necessity of meaningful relationships. Rosa emphasizes the importance of a common good in politics, advocating for deeper connections in an increasingly fragmented society. Amid discussions on navigating crises and defining a good life, he invites listeners to rethink community and engagement in this accelerated age.
Hartmut Rosa emphasizes the importance of 'resonance' as a means to reconnect individuals with a sense of transcendence beyond their personal desires.
The crisis of belonging in modern society is evident in the mental health struggles of young people, highlighting the need for community support.
Revitalizing the concept of the common good is essential for fostering dialogue and shared aspirations within a fragmented political landscape.
Deep dives
The Impact of Modernity on Spirituality
The current societal crisis is not solely spiritual or religious; it encapsulates a broader existential dilemma. In this modern age, many feel disconnected from a sense of transcendence, as suggested by the concept of the 'imminent frame.' This results in a narrow mindset where individual desires overshadow any inherent value beyond oneself. As a consequence, society faces significant challenges that are reflected not only in personal spirituality but also in political discourse, leading to a dichotomy where differing beliefs are often deemed as antagonistic rather than opportunities for dialogue.
Resonance as a Path to Understanding
Engagement with various wisdom traditions reveals the necessity for individuals and communities to foster a mode of listening that transcends mere control. The idea of 'resonance' emphasizes the value of being in touch with something greater than oneself, promoting a dynamic interplay rather than a one-dimensional perspective of modernity. This perspective is welcomed by many religious communities, as it aligns with their quest for deeper understanding and connection within their practices. Thus, the challenge is to cultivate an openness to listening and responding rather than dominating and controlling interactions.
The Shared Crisis of Control and Fear
In contemporary society, a pervasive fear drives individuals to accumulate resources in hopes of securing a stable future. Such fear stems from a lack of belonging and the notion that traditional supports—like community or family—can no longer be relied upon. Young people, in particular, face overwhelming mental health crises indicative of this deep-seated fear. As the velocity of modern life accelerates, it compels individuals to cling tightly to what is familiar, often resulting in a cycle of anxiety and isolation.
Reassessing the Concept of the Good Life
The discourse on the 'good life' has become fragmented, often viewed through the lens of individual choices rather than a collective aspiration. This modern sensibility has led to a crisis where traditional values and communal identities weaken, fostering a lack of direction for future generations. Without a shared understanding of the collective good, society risks fostering life experiences that are more shallow and disconnected from meaningful traditions. Thus, revitalizing the concept of the common good becomes essential for building coherence and direction in an increasingly pluralistic society.
Addressing Antagonism Through Political Dialogue
Political discourse often collapses into a battleground of opposing interests, neglecting a fundamental communal goal. The idea of a common good strives for the recognition that, despite differing beliefs and identities, there are shared aspirations that can unite individuals. A democratic society thrives when citizens collaboratively shape institutions based on mutual respect and understanding rather than hostility. Reestablishing dialogue that seeks to find resonance among differing views is crucial to fostering a more cohesive and empathetic political landscape.
I am thrilled to share my conversation with the renowned sociologist Hartmut Rosa. It was a unique and thought-provoking dialogue delving into the intricacies of modernity, control, and resonance. Rosa touches on various elements, from the role of resonance in a fulfilling life to the necessity of a common good in society, providing an insightful exploration into contemporary socio-political and spiritual issues.
If you want to get an introduction to Rosa’s main concepts and how they inspired the gathering at Princeton, you can listen to Andrew Root talk to me here. If you are interested in a deep dive into the work of Hartmut Rosa and Charles Taylor, then check out my class with Dr. Root - Religion & the Spiritual Crisis.