Physicist Brian Keating discusses his book Losing The Nobel Prize and the ill-fated BICEP2 announcement of primordial gravitational waves. Topics include mistaken interpretations, blunders and retractions in scientific research, the fear of being scooped by competitors, and the importance of seeking diverse perspectives.
Scientists are driven by passions, desires for recognition, and the pursuit of the Nobel Prize, not just rationality and unbiased pursuit of truth.
The Bicep 2 telescope faced financial limitations, data interpretation concerns, and the rush to secure the Nobel Prize, which ultimately impacted the experiment.
Deep dives
The distorted narrative around scientists
Scientists are not purely rational and unbiased observers seeking truth; they are driven by passions, desires for recognition, and even the pursuit of the Nobel Prize.
The Bicep 2 Telescope and its goals
The Bicep 2 telescope in the South Pole was designed to detect primordial gravitational waves, evidence of inflation and the origin of the universe. The telescope's potential discovery of B-modes, polarization patterns in cosmic microwave background radiation, generated excitement and speculation.
The challenges and risks of the Bicep 2 experiment
The Bicep 2 team faced financial limitations, limited data compared to the Planck satellite, and the need to minimize contamination from galactic dust. Despite the initial excitement, concerns about the data interpretation and the rush to secure the Nobel Prize plagued the experiment.
The problems with the Nobel Prize
The book explores the issues with the Nobel Prize, such as the limitation on single laureates, lack of inclusivity, and the prohibition on posthumous awards. The author proposes reforms, including allowing groups to win the prize and awarding posthumous prizes, to create a more equitable and meaningful recognition of scientific achievements.
In this special edition of the Foundational Questions Podcast, physicist Brian Keating discusses his book Losing The Nobel Prize, which recounts the ill-fated BICEP2 announcement--and retraction--of the claimed discovery of primordial gravitational waves in 2014. Listen for the special treat at the end. A poetic ode to cosmic dust.
🥗 Thanks, HelloFresh! Go to HelloFresh.com/50impossible and use code 50impossible for 50% off plus 15% off the next 2 months.
📝 With a MasterClass annual membership, you can take one-on-one classes from the world’s best for $10 a month with your annual membership, get unlimited access to every class — and even better, right now, as an Into The Impossible listener, you can get 15% off when you go to MASTERCLASS.com/impossible.